|
|
Post by psychokiller on Apr 11, 2014 21:02:02 GMT -5
Which 5 would you keep & which 5 would you fire?
|
|
|
|
Post by Mayonnaise on Apr 11, 2014 21:10:26 GMT -5
Keep (and in order):
Knux - Has all the tools, needs the proper direction.
MVP - Good enough on the mic and in the ring. Has the big star aura that TNA needs.
Magnus - Homegrown, talented just needs better booking around him
Willow - It's Hardy and I love the split personality stuff.
Gunner - IT'S F***ING GUNNER!
Fire:
Lashley - He brings nothing.
Kenny King - Still don't like what he did to ROH and Rhett Titus, nevermind he brings nothing but mediocre everything to the table.
Anderson - What is there to do with him? He is on face turn 513 and been a 3 time champ with each run being meaningless.
Robbie E. - Worse than drizzling shits.
Samuel Shaw - Potential but not above anyone in my keep pile.
|
|
|
|
Post by slappy on Apr 11, 2014 21:13:27 GMT -5
Do I have to keep 5? Can I keep 2 and get rid of 8?
|
|
Celgress
Bill S. Preston, Esq.
The Superior One
Posts: 19,009
|
Post by Celgress on Apr 11, 2014 21:17:04 GMT -5
Keep
Magnus
Willow
Samuel Shaw
Kenny King
Kunx
Fire
Bobby Lashley
Gunner
Mr. Anderson, Anderson!
Robbie E
MVP (if he remains in the authority figure role)
|
|
|
|
Post by psychokiller on Apr 11, 2014 21:21:05 GMT -5
Do I have to keep 5? Can I keep 2 and get rid of 8? NO! You must keep 5! |
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Apr 11, 2014 21:38:32 GMT -5
I kept Kenny King, Magnus, Anderson, MVP, and Shaw.
Even all of those are soft keeps. Magnus used to be a hard keep, but considering how hard they've been destroying his credibility, it's going to be tough to recover.
MVP is close to a hard keep, but not with his current face character. If you want him to be a face, you have to do better than what you've done thus far.
|
|
|
|
Post by slappy on Apr 11, 2014 21:39:09 GMT -5
Do I have to keep 5? Can I keep 2 and get rid of 8? NO! You must keep 5! Willow Magnus MVP Robbie E Lashley I'll keep Lashley but he must join the BroMans and be renamed Bob E. |
|
|
|
Post by psychokiller on Apr 11, 2014 21:47:48 GMT -5
Keep:
Knux - He has a lot of potential if given the chance. He's actually pretty good on the mic & is pretty underrated in the ring.
Mr. Anderson - Always been a big fan of his. He's entertaining to me & a recognizable face to keep around.
MVP - He's only just arrived & is one of the most recognizable talents they have. And he's great on the mic & good in the ring. Makes no sense to get rid of him.
Samuel Shaw - Has a lot of potential to make it far. He's doing a great job with the gimmick he has at the moment.
Willow - Not the biggest fan of this gimmick, but he could always return as himself. He's still young, has been clean for awhile now & is one of the biggest stars TNA has.
Fire
Bobby Lashley - He's been gone for way too long that no one cares about him anymore. Also, he's likely working a limited schedule for good money & I'd be surprised if he's even still in the company 6 months from now.
Gunner - I really wanted to keep him. He unfortunately got put in the 6th place spot. I think he's pretty underrated. He's solid in the ring & is decent on the mic. Just the other 5 either are already proven stars or have more potential in my opinion overall.
Kenny King - I wasn't that impressed with his last run in TNA. I never really seen any of his ROH work, but heard he left there on bad terms. This new gimmick seems like it could work for him, but going on what I've seen of him before I had to cut him.
Magnus - I'm just not a fan of him at all. Everything about him to me is just average at best. He's definitely not main event material.
Robbie E. - Not really bad in the ring or on the mic, the problem is he has an extremely stale gimmick. And he's at the very bottom of the 10 names listed where I just had to cut him.
|
|
|
|
Post by bluemeii on Apr 11, 2014 21:50:27 GMT -5
Keep
MVP - As bad an authority figure he is, he can still go and is still entertaining.
Kenny King - Good talent. Give him a chance with the new gimmick and see what happens.
Knux - Love his work, wanna see this carny character debut now.
Magnus - As bad as his championship reign was it shouldn't take too much to fix him back up.
Robbie E - Does the annoying douche well. Wrestling needs more heels you actually hate.
Fire
Mr. Anderson - Been meh on him for years. He's there it does nothing for me, he's gone I don't miss him.
Willow - If you had put Jeff Hardy on the list he'd be a keeper, but this gimmick just has to go.
Gunner - It's f***ing Gunner...at least if he was a heel I'd have a reason to hate him. He just needs to INTENSELY go away.
Samuel Shaw - Not digging on the whole stalker/murderer/crazy gimmick, personal reasons. Bigger thing with him is...what do they do with him next? Stalk another Knockout? Just seems like a one trick pony with no where to go when this whole Christy/Anderson thing is finally over.
Bobby Lashley - Reminds me too much of that guy in Grown Ups that comes and talks to the wives at the water park. I usually have the same reaction when Lashley opens his mouth as the wives did when the bodybuilder opened his.
(For those that don't know what I"m talking about)
|
|
|
|
Post by The Trashman on Apr 11, 2014 22:19:11 GMT -5
I couldnt pick 5 I would keep. Only got to 4
|
|
|
|
Post by psychokiller on Apr 11, 2014 22:22:25 GMT -5
I couldnt pick 5 I would keep. Only got to 4 Well than pick the one out of the 6 guys that you dislike the least. |
|
|
|
Post by king1836 on Apr 15, 2014 19:06:48 GMT -5
Keep (and in order): Knux - Has all the tools, needs the proper direction. MVP - Good enough on the mic and in the ring. Has the big star aura that TNA needs. Magnus - Homegrown, talented just needs better booking around him Willow - It's Hardy and I love the split personality stuff. Gunner - IT'S F***ING GUNNER! Fire: Lashley - He brings nothing. Kenny King - Still don't like what he did to ROH and Rhett Titus, nevermind he brings nothing but mediocre everything to the table. Anderson - What is there to do with him? He is on face turn 513 and been a 3 time champ with each run being meaningless. Robbie E. - Worse than drizzling shits. Samuel Shaw - Potential but not above anyone in my keep pile.
Fire Samuel Shaw? That is blasphemy!
|
|
|
|
Post by Harry The Arrow was Wrong! on Apr 16, 2014 10:06:39 GMT -5
Keep
Samuel Shaw - Has a lot of potential and an interesting character
Knux - Highly underrated, great look, decent on the mic and good in the ring
Ken Anderson - Always liked Ken especially when he's a heel
Gunner - Keeps getting better and it's f***ING GUNNER
Magnus - Talented and has a good look, he just needs to be booked better
Fire
Bobby Lashley - Zero personality, Zero charisma and just not that good
MVP - Don't hate him by any means, I just prefer the 5 I selected to keep
Kenny King - See above
Robbie E - Just f***ing terrible. Needs to get off my TV now.
Willow - Do I really need explain this. Terrible, terrible character.
|
|
|
|
Post by TK The Friendly Robot on Apr 16, 2014 10:09:31 GMT -5
I see no need to get rid of any of these guys. I just think they need to add more guys to the fold, rather than lose anyone at this point. I'd keep Bad Influence and Sabin if I could though and kick Abyss and James Storm to the curb instead though. They should also get round to releasing Garret Bischoff and Hernandez, although only if it's a one in and one out kind of deal. Then need more new talent.
|
|
|
|
Post by Andrew is Good on Apr 16, 2014 21:02:58 GMT -5
Kept:
Gunner: After that whole bunch of vignettes, Gunner really started to impress me. He's getting a lot better.
MVP: He's a talker above and beyond a lot of the pack, and is a welcome addition.
Magnus: He pretty much has the total package so definitely.
Kenny King: Pretty much the same as above, it's surprising he's not pushed more.
Robbie E: I've always been a fan of his, and I think you can go a lot further with him then just a comedy character.
Fired:
Willow: This whole gimmick has pretty much killed off Jeff Hardy's drawing potential in TNA. TNA has kinda did a number on it anyway, since he was an afterthought when he was brought in on the Jan 4 2010, when he was the biggest star of the bunch, but overshadowed by Hogan and crew.
Bobby Lashley: He's got the look, but I just don't think he's been made into a worthy investment.
Mr. Anderson: If Mr. Anderson can stop cutting Mr. Anderson promos, he'd be kept. He's an incredible talent when he's serious.
Samuel Shaw: Bad gimmick, but he plays it well.
Knux: Don't seem to know why he's still around. Must be cheap.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Apr 16, 2014 21:35:18 GMT -5
Well... I'm not sure about keeping/firing any but you can look at my siggy and know which 5 I'd bring back.
Hell with it. No. They're better outside of TNA for their own sake. I used to think "at least they were making money" but after seeing what happened to Joe and knowing that they're not I honestly think they'd do better elsewhere.
|
|
|
|
Post by Magic knows Black Lives Matter on Apr 16, 2014 21:59:42 GMT -5
KEEP:
1. f***ing Gunner- I don't want to think of a TNA without f***ing Gunner.
2. Willow- Always been a huge fan of Hardy and he's the biggest star in the company. Willow sucks ass but Hardy should stay.
3. MVP- Plays his role well and is one of the few guys that carries himself like a big star in the company.
4. Magnus- To his credit, he's improving as a top heel. He's still not very good but hey, A for effort.
5. Knux- Solid talent.
FIRE:
1. Robbie E- The BroMans are freaking terrible tag champs. TNA has booked them to oblivion and they are such goobers they are impossible to take seriously
2. Samuel Shaw- The character had potential but TNA has made it a joke with this Christy storyline.
3. Mr. Anderson- f*** Anderson
4. Lashley- LOL, why is even still here?
5. King- I don't hate him but he doesn't really bring anything to the table that someone doesn't do better.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Apr 17, 2014 0:06:54 GMT -5
I'd keep Sam Shaw, but fire Anderson and get Hemme off TV as they are WRECKING (and not in a good way, like you want) that whole thing.
|
|
|
|
Post by Oh Cry Me a Screwball on Apr 17, 2014 0:23:45 GMT -5
Keep:
Jeff Hardy: So long as he can stay on the wagon, I'm fine with having a top draw and merchandise mover. But this Willow crap is undermining him so badly.
Knux: Here's a great powerhouse that I can't believe WWE let go. I'm even interested to see if he can make anything out of his carny gimmick he's going to have.
Magnus: I'm not sure he's main event material like TNA seems to think, but he is quite a heat Magnet.
Kenny King: We need all the X-Division we can get, and he's got more charisma than his peers.
MVP: TNA needs good promos really badly right now, and he really seems revitalized from all the time he's spent in Japan.
Drop
Robbie E: I actually don't have a problem with Robbie E, but he doesn't have anything to keep him from inching out someone in the Keep 5 list.
Bobby Lashley: Bobby Lashley has all the potential in the world, but do I trust him with a spot befitting that potential when he he decides he wants to do something else? The difference between him and Lesnar is that Lesnar is a proven draw unlike Lashley, and WWE has enough money to keep his attention span in check.
Samuel Shaw: Much like Robbie, I don't really hate him, but he hasn't shown me anything besides the ability to rip off an HBO Showtime series.
Mr. Anderson: The dude is stale as hell, has never been particularly impressive (save in one role), and has peaked in this company. He's a damn good heel, as his Aces and Eights run showed, but I've got heels just as good on the other side of this list with more potential.
Gunner: f***ing Gunner. I don't know why he's getting the big babyface push, but kudos to TNA for actually getting people behind him. But he's nothing but f***ing Gunner to me.
|
|
|
|
Post by king1836 on Apr 17, 2014 5:52:49 GMT -5
Keep: Jeff Hardy: So long as he can stay on the wagon, I'm fine with having a top draw and merchandise mover. But this Willow crap is undermining him so badly. Knux: Here's a great powerhouse that I can't believe WWE let go. I'm even interested to see if he can make anything out of his carny gimmick he's going to have. Magnus: I'm not sure he's main event material like TNA seems to think, but he is quite a heat Magnet. Kenny King: We need all the X-Division we can get, and he's got more charisma than his peers. MVP: TNA needs good promos really badly right now, and he really seems revitalized from all the time he's spent in Japan. Drop Robbie E: I actually don't have a problem with Robbie E, but he doesn't have anything to keep him from inching out someone in the Keep 5 list. Bobby Lashley: Bobby Lashley has all the potential in the world, but do I trust him with a spot befitting that potential when he he decides he wants to do something else? The difference between him and Lesnar is that Lesnar is a proven draw unlike Lashley, and WWE has enough money to keep his attention span in check. Samuel Shaw: Much like Robbie, I don't really hate him, but he hasn't shown me anything besides the ability to rip off an HBO series. Mr. Anderson: The dude is stale as hell, has never been particularly impressive (save in one role), and has peaked in this company. He's a damn good heel, as his Aces and Eights run showed, but I've got heels just as good on the other side of this list with more potential. Gunner: f***ing Gunner. I don't know why he's getting the big babyface push, but kudos to TNA for actually getting people behind him. But he's nothing but f***ing Gunner to me.
I respectfully disagree, Sir. Dexter was on Showtime, not HBO. Also, I feel that Shaw is more like American Psycho. TNA needs to hold on to him. WWE wouldn't know what to do with him.
|
|
