Which was the WORST WWE Draft?

[bubbles]

2007, that year was crap.

[thedon]

2007 by far

By the next draft, 7 of them were released

[Loki]

2007 hands down.

But this year's can be a great move or another of those missed chances

[James McCloud IS John Godot]

2004. It was like they accidentally broadcast the Supplemental Draft instead.

[Stone Coke Miami Watson 🥃]

2007 overall....but 2008, reason being ECW getting poo'd on draft-wise.

[SickFlipPiledriver]

This one draft I did on Smackdown: Shut Your Mouth.

RAW's second pick was Rhino.

[Deleted]

Are wee counting the Supplemental draft as well?

[nyfleaman]

I thought the 2005 one was great, mainly because the brands still felt really separate. And it had a slow build as to who was on what show, and could make a really big deal. Nowadays, we get all 3 brands fighting on the same show a lot of times. Doesn't feel like its different.

2007's was garbage.

[metylerca]

2007 because the only redeeming draft selection ended up killing his family/self.

And also, Flair went to Smackdown, lost to Khali... and then showed up on RAW in November

[BorneAgain]

Hell the supplemental draft in 2007 had a bigger impact long term than the main draft. Miz and Morrison (then Nitro) were both drafted to ECW and more or less ending up making their careers there.

[Pooh Carlson]

After whats been happening with the supplemental draft this year, 2009 is the worst. Come on, they just split the Unified Tag Champions!

[Bub (BLM)]

2005. I'm a very impatient person, so the long, drawn out drafter really irritated me. I just wanted instant, drastic change rather than a slow process.

[Marvelously Mediocre]

raw did not dominate 08 at all

[thuschongswing]

Apr 15, 2009 12:54:52 GMT -5 Pooh Carlson said:

After whats been happening with the supplemental draft this year, 2009 is the worst. Come on, they just split the Unified Tag Champions!

Considering how lax the brand split is when it comes to tag teams (see: In Crowd, The), this doesn't concern me all that much since they'll both - in all likelihood - show up on each of the three brands each week.

I picked 2007 as the worst. No need for me to explain in detail why.

[Fishbone is Marshall Law]

This years draft was poop.
Just poop...

[>(straightedgepunk)<]

2007 was garbage. SmackDown was utterly destroyed by RAW. The only good drafts were Benoit and Nitro. We all know how the first one turned out. Even saying Nitro was a good draft is pushing it. The only reason behind saying his draft was good is because a couple of months later he would become John Morrison.

[Arturo Classico]

This years because all the picks i could see coming a mile a way and had zero surprises. I honestly like the 07 draft, had huge surprises but in the long run it didn't pan out but at the time the people that were drafted seemed good just horrible luck.

[Hiroshi Hase]

Apr 15, 2009 9:17:58 GMT -5 James McCloud IS John Godot said:

2004. It was like they accidentally broadcast the Supplemental Draft instead.

You mean to tell me you weren't on the edge of your seat for such talents like Spike Dudley and Mark Jindrak being drafted?