|
Post by Triple H buried SnS on Jul 8, 2010 9:31:20 GMT -5
ok i've been gone awhile and i dont know when i'll be able to get back on so whats funny about Doley being mafia SNS? Doley signs up, and is inactive. We almost lynch him via "lunch the lurker" then he gets replaced, so we don't lynch him. Then he turns out to be mafia anyway and gets killed by the serial killer.
|
|
Jazzman
King Koopa
Trombone Shorty > Your Favorite Musician
Posts: 11,231
|
Post by Jazzman on Jul 8, 2010 9:42:50 GMT -5
Everyone:
Everything in my personal life is fine, I'm just overstretched here in the games forum. I'm judgin WC Idol Season 3, still competing in WWCF, and am back to work 30 hours a week. I just needed to drop something and sadly, it was this.
|
|
|
Post by Brandon Walsh is Insane. on Jul 8, 2010 13:51:37 GMT -5
I'm all for a continuation of the game.
Just as Scruffy, I would like to know about Doley being mafia, SNS.
And Herr Hund -- I feel really bad about leading the charge against ritt. He was playing differently than usual and it through me off.
Looking back, I would still vote the way I did. I do think those that voted alongside me should be questioned though, as my reasoning for a vote wasn't the strongest, and they followed suit.
Thus far, no one has really stuck straight out as scum to me, and that is worrying, seeing that they are able to hide in the background too easily.
|
|
|
Post by Triple H buried SnS on Jul 8, 2010 14:02:45 GMT -5
I didn't get why everyone else wasn't finding it funny about doley being an inactive mafia, getting replaced, then getting night killed right away. ...Then I realized... I got D2 and Dom mixed up... Doley may or may not be mafia, but he wasn't replaced by dom... he was replaced by D2, who is still alive...
|
|
|
Post by Allison Reynolds on Jul 9, 2010 9:05:06 GMT -5
Nice to have you onboard as the new GM Ritt! Hope we can get this game underway, all the way to the end! Ritt what's the deadline?
Okay, now that we know Ritt is the new GM, let's continue, the hunt. Who does everyone suspect? Let's put some FoS and Votes out.
|
|
|
Post by Triple H buried SnS on Jul 9, 2010 9:45:34 GMT -5
Lots has changed in a day:
My previous lists:
Probable town GDR - Right! - dead Sudden rush Hund
Most suspicious of: Michael Hayden The Dom - Right! - dead Ritt - WRONG! - dead Scruffy(added later in another post)
------------
My new list of suspicions(this time listing everyone)
Almost certain is town... if not, he's played me/us well: Jonathan Michaels
Probably Town: Sudden Rush
Undecided: D2(aka doley) - Have NO read yet
Scruffy - I was suspicious of you earlier. But I don't remember why now. I can't find anything where I accused you of anything, or us even talking about why I found you suspicious. So dropping you to undecided for now.
Warryah - Have NO read yet
Most suspicious of: Hayden - Still getting a bad vibe from you. You focused alot on GDR - First "jumping on the bandwaggon" and voting GDR giving him his 4th vote before he even had a chance to respond - then, when he role claimed, stated that mafia would have joined in on that bandwaggon - and now today saying that mafia killed him to throw people off track. You are all over the place, and causing confusion and keeping people off balance. Something that Mafia love to do.
Hund - Sawyers breakdown is pretty impressive. And I don't know if its just because I want to believe it, or that your response to it just doesn't hold up to the accusation, but you are here for the time being.
|
|
|
Post by ritt works hard fo da chickens on Jul 9, 2010 16:57:55 GMT -5
Carry on folks and goodluck. I hope this can stay fun for everyone. I will do my best.
|
|
|
Post by Brandon Walsh is Insane. on Jul 9, 2010 19:47:19 GMT -5
I didn't get why everyone else wasn't finding it funny about doley being an inactive mafia, getting replaced, then getting night killed right away. ...Then I realized... I got D2 and Dom mixed up... Doley may or may not be mafia, but he wasn't replaced by dom... he was replaced by D2, who is still alive... I made an oversight early on too, so I understand where you're coming from.
|
|
|
Post by ritt works hard fo da chickens on Jul 10, 2010 18:10:17 GMT -5
I just realized that there is no timeframe for this day to end set yet. Is Wednesday night ok by everyone or would you all need some more time?
|
|
|
Post by Allison Reynolds on Jul 10, 2010 19:37:58 GMT -5
Wednesday sounds good, so that way people will be inclined to put up their thoughts/votes as soon as possible before deadline.
Come on guys, lets play. I vote we vote Herr Hund, anyone besides Hund, oppose? If so, give your own suspect for us to vote for. We only need 5 votes, and we have 4 days left.
|
|
|
Post by ritt works hard fo da chickens on Jul 11, 2010 18:55:39 GMT -5
Prods have been requested, but since I have just taken the reigns and it is a weekend I will give a full days grace period. Anyone who hasn't posted though within 72 hours by 11pm board time Monday night will receive prods from me.
|
|
|
Post by Triple H buried SnS on Jul 11, 2010 23:45:20 GMT -5
vote: hund
sounds good,let's get this ball rolling
|
|
|
Post by Brandon Walsh is Insane. on Jul 12, 2010 11:00:39 GMT -5
I like the reasoning for Hund... I really do.
I also feel like we are being pushed by Rush a bit too easily.
I'm unsure which way to place my vote at the moment.
|
|
|
Post by Chuckie Finster on Jul 12, 2010 11:08:13 GMT -5
After Dom was turned as mafia, I doubted everyone I associated with as mafia. I questioned Warryah and really, my mind keeps on going back to Sawyer. Trying to push a quick vote, thinking she has control of the game, it fits my suspicions for mafia.
Vote: Sawyer
It basically comes down to who you believe. I hope people side with me as I know I'm not mafia and eliminating me won't help us win.
|
|
|
Post by D2: Sweet & Sour Edition on Jul 12, 2010 12:14:52 GMT -5
Whew, did you guys miss me? First time I've had internet connection in over a week, so I'll make things short and sweet.
Suspicions, suspicions. We all have them. But who more than others? I've had gut feelings like this before, and they've turned out right. May as well stake what little reputation I have on this one too.
Vote: Sawyer
|
|
|
Post by Brandon Walsh is Insane. on Jul 12, 2010 13:09:17 GMT -5
The last two votes make me feel like Hund and D2 are in cahoots.
I am weary of Rush/Sawyer, but these two votes solidify Hund and D2 being partners in crime.
Hund I can see, since it's basically voting against the person that voted for him; however, D2 has been more of an under the radar player this game, not really adding anything to the mafia hunt... and all of a sudden votes without doubt against Sawyer.
This brings me to:
FOS: D2
VOTE: Herr Hund
|
|
|
Post by Allison Reynolds on Jul 13, 2010 1:34:46 GMT -5
I just had a revelation. {Spoiler}For Herr Hund: If you really aren't mafia, like you said so, then I need your cooperation please. I just had some De-Ja-Vu with what happened in the WC2 Mafia Game, where I lead a lynch against The Dom, and he flipped townie. Embarassing you know, and it hurts the rep in scum-hunting. I started from the beginning and re-read the thread. I had to look for your possible 'partners' if you were actually mafia. I also looked back for back-up suspects, just in case you are actually a townie. I didn't want to get stuck, with nothing, if you flipped townie, like The Dom in my last game. I did find two other suspects who look like they could be partnered. I can't say who right now, as that will mess things up if I am right about Herr Hund being mafia. Herr Hund, I need some of your help if you are really town. I have to let you say your side of the story: 1. Who, aside from myself (I'm not mafia either) do you suspect might be possible mafia members now? List all of your suspects and why please. 2. Who do you think might be the good football player townies? These questions will help me back up my thoughts on you being mafia/townie, or if my two other suspects are the real mafia. You see, Herr Hund, I do find you the scummiest right now, that's why I put my vote on you. I also feel that my vote is best on you for the now, because if you flip and are revealed townie, then I know where to look to next. *Eyes other two suspects* However, your next couple of post could help me decide if you are innocent or not. I'd really like you to be able to prove me wrong, and change my focus onto someone else. I can't unvote you right now though, as I'm next in line for the lynch. Gotta save my own skin, you know. I wish the vote was simpler, and you are just Mafia as Expected.
|
|
|
Post by Chuckie Finster on Jul 13, 2010 2:43:00 GMT -5
Well since I'm so close to being lynched, I might as well fight for myself.
Right now, the people I'm thinking are safest are D2 and Michaels. D2 has only posted twice IIRC since he took over Doley's spot and neither have really been much. I know he came in and voted for Sawyer, but I feel like that might be because of past games. Michaels targeted Dom and was right due to blind luck in my opinion. But still, he was right.
Scruffy I'm cold on. He's been not as active lately so reading him is hard. He's been rather reasonable so far so he's fine, although he or SnS are probably Henry.
SnS I must say I'm on edge more now that he voted against me. I've had him in “probable town” for a while, but I now have him on the fence since he voted for me and seems like a bandwagon jumper. Part of it might be eagerness as he's been wanting to know the rules. Of it might be his cover for being Henry.
Hayden is my borderline person. I guess there's only two mafia left, but I'm not sure. If there's a third, he's it in my opinion. He's not posted in a while and I think he's waiting to be the lynchpin, so to speak. He jumped on my Doley bandwagon and also on the GDR bangwadon.
My twosome of terror are Warryah and Sawyer. Warryah has been very hesitant to name people mafia and said the only good read he had was on Ritt, who ended up town. The D2 connection to me he made makes little sense. As I said, he's only been in since he took Doley's place in the middle of Day 2. D2 is the kind of person who would thrive on being mafia and post more often. D2's vote against Sawyer, as I said, is probably not due to my argument but rather past games. I noted my suspicions of him before he voted for me.
Sawyer....what can I say. I feel that your the most trusted person in these mafia games. You have dictated your will against me early and often. You came in late to try to save Ritt which I feel was a plan as no one changed their votes. It made you look good thus you could gain more trust against me as I named you. Pushing for a quick vote against me, prodding me to make an effort to save myself, it all reeks.
No, I don't expect you to change your vote. I never did. I probably did you a favor just now by spilling my guts. I feel like I've let all of us down. I named GDR and Michaels and was wrong on one and I'm probably wrong on the other as well. Now me being proactive and trying to spearhead us against the scum is turning in my face.
Sawyer, you were wondering why everyone was quiet and afraid to speak? Well, this is why.
|
|
|
Post by Triple H buried SnS on Jul 13, 2010 8:30:31 GMT -5
I figured you would put me up as a suspect after voting you(it is almost expected in this game)... but badwaggon vote? I believe I was the first person to vote for you on this day.
|
|
|
Post by Allison Reynolds on Jul 13, 2010 10:34:46 GMT -5
Defending Myself: {Spoiler} Sawyer....what can I say. I feel that your the most trusted person in these mafia games. You have dictated your will against me early and often. You came in late to try to save Ritt which I feel was a plan as no one changed their votes. It made you look good thus you could gain more trust against me as I named you. Pushing for a quick vote against me, prodding me to make an effort to save myself, it all reeks. Y: I see what you are trying to say, but nothing like this happened. Your theory on Me/TheDom/Warryah coming up with an elaborate plot to have two vote for Ritt, and for me to fight it, to try and look townie, while I put the blame on my two "team-mates" in an effort to gain trust to make you look guilty because you named me as a suspect is wrong. I am nowhere near that clever to mastermind something like that, even before you named me a suspect. I tried my best to keep people from voting Ritt, and for some to unvote. It's not my fault they didn't. I even pushed heavily on Warryah, with my suspicions, so your not the only one Herr Hund. In fact I had only a passing suspicion, like every game. It wasn't until your sudden suspicion of me, after responding to The Dom's suspicious post (page 13), that I started to raise my eyebrow on you. I let it go though, because I was still focused on Warryah, and thought that it was just a misunderstanding. That is, until you continued with your accusations against me. In fact, you voted for me the scummiest player. Being that I know that I am not scum, I had to defend myself, against reasons that I knew weren't true. P: I'm not pushing a quick lynch on you. I found you the most likely to be scum, so that's where my vote goes. There is nothing wrong with trying to persuade others to vote with you. No one else was giving any other options/reasons, so I am trying to get people to vote who I felt was the best lynch. I did this early this time, because I was too late with it to get you Herr Hund lynched day 2, and too late with it to stop someone else's bandwagon from lynching someone I found innocent in Ritt. What is bad about letting you give your side? Or as you call it "prodding you to save yourself"? I learned from the past to let people to give their side, and to give their own suspects/innocent reads, as to expand our information for the future 'days', and to maybe prevent a mislynch. No, I don't expect you to change your vote. I never did. I probably did you a favor just now by spilling my guts. I feel like I've let all of us down. I named GDR and Michaels and was wrong on one and I'm probably wrong on the other as well. Now me being proactive and trying to spearhead us against the scum is turning in my face.
Sawyer, you were wondering why everyone was quiet and afraid to speak? Well, this is why. Y: Don't be too hard on yourself, it happens. Don't take things too personally dude, it's all ingame, And your post did help a bit. P: In Summary, all this non-activity (Quietness, Not Speaking & Participating) in the mafia games, is all my fault? I feel really bad now. I'm sorry, I am not trying to discourage people from participating. What I'm trying to do is, if I think someone is innocent, or a case against someone just isn't logical, then I'll try to defend the person as much as I can. Like with Ritt. Or if someone puts their case against me as mafia, then of course I'm gonna defend myself, against it, since I know I am NOT Mafia Scum. I think it's time to give my own list, just in case I get killed before Day 4. My List: {Spoiler}Possible Scum: Herr Hund
With Scruffy as his partner.
Safe: Jonathan Michaels D2 The Warryah Michael Hayden SnS Me
OR if he's innocent then, Possible Scum: The Warryah
With Michael Hayden OR SnS as his partner.
Safe: Jonathan Michaels Scruffy D2 Michael Hayden OR SnS Herr Hund Me
What do you guys think? Should I switch back to Warryah?
|
|