|
Post by Joker on Mar 16, 2012 5:51:57 GMT -5
I haven't done this in a while so I will need two lists ...
Please send your Top 30 Superheros and your Top 30 Supervillains to me via PM or by posting in this thread. If you only send one half then your vote will be null. If you don't order them from 1 - 30 it will be null as well.
This is so both sides of the coin are represented fairly.
I will be entering my own lists, which I will put in the main thread so everyone can see.
I will stop vote taking in a month's time.
FAQ time:
How do the points and scoring work? Easy. Number one on your lists will get 30 points, whilst number 30 will get 1 point. I will then tally up all the scores and make the countdown from that.
Who can we vote for? I will only accept DC, Marvel or similar comic book heroes and villains (e.g Hellboy or Witchblade). There will be no historical, comedy, TV or Manga creations allowed in this. (e.g The Ninja turtles, Dr. Who, Transformers, Captain Caveman, Hong Kong Phooey, Akira, Heroes, Captain Nemo (LGX) or Dragonball.) If in doubt ask me first.
What about Mercenaries I hear you ask or those both side of the fence people? Characters like that may go on either list but only once per person voting. So for example if you think Venom is more of a hero then put him on that side, but you can't put him on both.
Can we put in groups? No you can't, so don't vote for The Justice league or Fantastic Four as a single entrant.
What if a guy has more than one incarnation like the The Flash? For those characters who have had more than one guy behind the mask, vote for both there identity and the name as one choice.
E.g - Number 7. The Flash (Barry Allen) would be your only vote for The Flash.
What are we basing are vote on? This is purely on who you like the most. If you think Jean Grey is the greatest then put her as your number one choice of hero. if you think Trapster is an awesome villain put him at number 1 on your villain list. If you only like DC comics, only vote for DC characters. It's that simple.
What if I can't think of 30 heroes and 30 villains? Google a list of supervillains or superheroes I'm sure Wiki or another webstie can help remind you of all the heroic and dastardly characters around.
So I now await two lists of 30 heroes and villains from you fine people.
Let the voting begin, will heroes or villains be the ultimate winners? Can DC pound Marvel into the dirt? or will Shocker shock the world?? (Not likely)
Any further questions let me know!
|
|
|
Post by Wolf Hurricane on Mar 16, 2012 6:31:30 GMT -5
What about reverse order, i.e. 30 to 1?
|
|
Big Bad Brad
Wade Wilson
Big Bad Brad
Tournament Master
Posts: 27,409
|
Post by Big Bad Brad on Mar 16, 2012 6:36:57 GMT -5
I'll try to come up with a list later
|
|
|
Post by Joker on Mar 16, 2012 11:09:03 GMT -5
What about reverse order, i.e. 30 to 1? As long as there is an obvious order with 1 being your most favorite and 30 being the least favorite thats fine.
|
|
|
Post by Loki-A-Go-Go! on Mar 16, 2012 11:56:06 GMT -5
Does The Tick count as comedy?
|
|
|
Post by Big DSR Energy on Mar 16, 2012 13:22:01 GMT -5
Does Harley Quinn count? She debuted on TV first, then wound up in the comics continuity.
Also, what about Squirrel Girl?
|
|
Fiddleford H. McGucket
El Dandy
My Mind's been gone for 30-odd years! Can't Break what's already broken!
Posts: 8,748
|
Post by Fiddleford H. McGucket on Mar 16, 2012 13:29:25 GMT -5
Ok.....Quick question, What about characters from FABLES? It's a comic series by Vertigo "starring" Classic literary characters. The infamy I'm using for the Villain I'm listing though is SOLELY based on the comics version of the character, not the actual literary version.
|
|
|
Post by Joker on Mar 16, 2012 15:08:22 GMT -5
If there main source is comics then that is fine, so Yes to Harley Quinn, Yes to the Tick, Yes to Squirrel girl, Vertigo comics are fine.
|
|
|
Post by Joker on Mar 16, 2012 16:12:09 GMT -5
My lists
Superheroes 1.Ghost Rider (Johnny Blaze) 2.Spider-Man 3.The Flash (Wally West) 4.Iron Man 5.Doctor Strange 6.Batman 7.Daredevil 8.Invisible Woman 9.Cyclops 10.Deadpool 11.Silver Surfer 12.Multiple Man 13.Captain Britain 14.The Incredible Hulk 15.Atomic Robo 16.Wolverine 17.Mr. Terrific 18.Superman 19.Psylocke 20.Green Lantern (Hal Jordan) 21.Rorshach 22.Captain America 23.Raven 24.The Question 25.Mr. Immortal 26.Power Girl 27.Black Cat 28.Sleepwalker 29.Hellboy 30.Prodigy
Supervillains 1.Joker 2.Mysterio (Quentin Beck) 3.Mr. Sinister 4.Doctor Octopus 5.Shuma-Gorath 6.The Scarecrow (DC) 7.Blackheart 8.Doctor Doom 9.Sinestro 10.Mr. Freeze 11.Brainiac 12.Annihilus 13.Red Skull 14.Dormammu 15.Carnage 16.Captain Cold 17.Two-Face 18.Magneto 19.The Lizard 20.MODOK 21.Johnny Sorrow 22.Juggernaut 23.Baron Zemo 24.Larfleeze 25.Shocker 26.Thanos 27. Morbius 28.Doctor Dinosaur 29.Crimson Dynamo 30.Nekron
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Mar 16, 2012 17:37:36 GMT -5
SuperHeroes 1.Psylocke 2.Nightcrawler 3.Batman 4.Spiderman 5.Wolverine 6.Green Lantern(John Stewart) 7.Zatanna 8.PowerGirl 9.SilverSurfer 10.Red SheHulk(betty ross) 11.Superman 12.The Flash (Bart Allen) 13.Cosmic Boy 14Lightning Lad 15.Green Arrow 16.HellBoy 17.Ironman 18.DeadPool 19.Bishop 20.Donna Troy 21.SuperGirl(Kara Zor-El) 22.Black Lightning 23.Blade 24.BoosterGold 25.Captain America 26.Kitty Pryde 27.Spawn (al simmons) 28.WonderWoman 29.Martian Manhunter 30.Captain Marvel(DC)
SuperVillans. 1.Thanos 2.Apocalypse 3.Mr Sinister 4.Lex Luthor 5.Parasite 6.Galactus 7.Dark Phoenix 8.Vandal Savage 9The Joker 10.Doomsday 11.Star Sapphire (Carol Ferris) 12.Solomon Grundy 13.DeadShot 14.Gorill Grod 15.DeathStroke 16.Zoom 17.General Zod 18.Imperiex 19.Ultron 20.Carnage 21.Mystique 22.Brainiac 23.Black Adam 24.Norman Osborn 25.Sinestro 26.DoctorDoom 27.Harley Quinn 28.Darkseid 29.Poison Ivy 30.Mandarin
This was way more difficult than I expected it to be but looking it over a few dozen times looks to be fine I hope.
|
|
|
Post by Big DSR Energy on Mar 16, 2012 22:35:32 GMT -5
One more question: I'm gonna have Marvel's Captain Marvel and DC's Captain Marvel on my list. If I give you the character's alter-ego or whatever in parentheses, is that cool?
Actually, two more questions: Is it okay to use Apache Chief, of the Super Friends?
|
|
|
Post by RI Richmark on Mar 17, 2012 0:02:28 GMT -5
Just to let you know I haven't read much comics outside of Runaways. Most of my knowledge of these heroes & villains comes from their portrayal in other media like cartoons & movies.
Superheroes: 1. Chase Stein 2. Victor Mancha 3. Molly Hayes 4. Gertrude Yorkes 5. Nico Minoru 6. Karolina Dean 7. Xavin 8. Klara Plast 9. Old Lace 10. Spider-Man 11. Superman 12. Iron Man 13. Hulk 14. Captian America 15. Dr. Hank Pym 16. Wasp 17. Batman 18. Nick Fury 19. Flash (Wally West) 20. Robin (Dick Grayson) 21. Cyclops 22. Wolverine 23. The Thing 24. Stature 25. Nightcrawler 26. She-Hulk 27. Luke Cage 28. Static 29. Starfire 30. Green Lantern (John Stewart)
Supervillians: 1. Alex Wilder 2. Lex Luther 3. Magneto 4. Venom 5. Dr. Octopus 6. Ultron 7. Joker 8. Bane 9. Dr. Doom 10. Darksied 11. Avalanche 12. Juggernaut 13. Geoffrey Wilder 14. Kingpin 15. Loki 16. Red Skull 17. Sandman (Marvel) 18. Scarecrow (DC) 19. Ra's al Ghul 20. Mr. Freeze 21. Green Goblin 21. Two Face 22. Penguin 23. Giganta 24. Victor Stein 25. Kraven the Hunter 26. Rhino 27. Harley Quinn 28. Mr. Mxyzptlk 29. Shocker 30. Zod
|
|
|
Post by Joker on Mar 17, 2012 7:51:49 GMT -5
One more question: I'm gonna have Marvel's Captain Marvel and DC's Captain Marvel on my list. If I give you the character's alter-ego or whatever in parentheses, is that cool? Actually, two more questions: Is it okay to use Apache Chief, of the Super Friends? Both are fine if you just want to say captain marvel (marvel) Captain marvel (dc) thats fine. Apache Chief is allowed.
|
|
|
Post by Loki-A-Go-Go! on Mar 17, 2012 11:49:15 GMT -5
Super Hereos:
1. Cyclops 2. Warlock (New Mutants) 3. Spider Man 4. The Flash (Wally West) 5. Thunderbird (John Proudstar) 6. Daredevil 7. Red Hood (Jason Todd) 8. The Tick 9. HellBoy 10. Mister Fantastic 11. Batman 12. Plastic Man 13. Giant Man (Henry Pym) 14. Vibe (Paco Ramone) 15. Steel (Hank Heywood III) 16. Dove (Dawn Granger) 17. Hawk (Hank Hall) 18. The Black Cat 19. The Hulk 20. Guy Gardner 21. Colossus 22. Blue Beetle (Ted Kord) 23. The Thing 24. Husk 25. Silver Surfer 26. Beak 27. Magik (Illyana Rasputin) 28. Jack of Hearts 29. Dazzler 30. The Comedian
Super Villains:
1. The Riddler 2. Clayface (Matt Hagen) 3. Magneto 4. Dr. Doom 5. Kraven the Hunter 6. The Vulture 7. Dr. Octopus 8. Bizarro 9. The Ventriloquist (Arnold Wesker) 10. Hydro Man 10. Sandman (Marvel) 11. The Joker 12. Venom (Eddie Brock) 13. Carnage 14. Eclipso 15. Poison ivy 16. Mr. Mxyzptlk 17. The Mad Hatter (Jervis Tetch) 18. Mysterio (Quentin Beck) 19. The Beyonder 20. Thanos 21. Two Face 22. Mr Sinister 23. Bane 24. Doomsday 25. Red Skull 26. Loki 27. Ra's al Ghul 28. Green Goblin (Bart Hamilton) 29. Sinestro 30. Brainiac
|
|
|
Post by Joker on Mar 18, 2012 8:37:33 GMT -5
Keep them coming, getting a strong selection so far.
|
|
Fiddleford H. McGucket
El Dandy
My Mind's been gone for 30-odd years! Can't Break what's already broken!
Posts: 8,748
|
Post by Fiddleford H. McGucket on Mar 18, 2012 15:30:02 GMT -5
Ok....Debating putting my lists up here. I'm going tolevel though, I thought about this after the fac and realize I left off a LOT on both sides. When making the list I basically went with both Who was most "Important" as well as characters that personally brought me the most joy as a reader basically whether thier appearance or non-appearance would sell the book for me.
Villains: 30. Mad Hatter 29. Clayface (Matt Hagan) 28. Doctor Sivana 27. Revise (JACK OF FABLES) 26. Mr. Dark (FABLES) 25. Trigon 24. Deathstroke 23. Magog (Kingdom Come) 22. Two-Face 21. Vandal Savage 20. Hugo Strange 19. Geopetto (FABLES) 18. Darkseid 17. Kingpin 16. Carnage 15 Ras Al Ghul 14. Venom 13. Reverse Flash 12. Scarecrow 11. Solomon Grundy 10. Riddler 9. Mr. Mxysptlk 8. Harley Quinn 7. Sinestro 6. Bane 5. Norman Osborne 4. Reverend Striker (God loves, Man Kills) 3. Black Adam 2. Joker 1. Lex Luthor
An explanation of my Top 3. As evil as Joker is, I put Lex over because at the end of the day Joker is a criminal, Lex Luthor is evil......but he's got enought "Real" power to do some of the most evil schemes completely legit too. Joker could never be President.
Hero List: 30. Bat Mite 29. Squirrel Girl 28. Animal Man 27. Beast (Hank McCoy) 26. Cyborg 25. Kilawog 24. Hellboy 23. Booster Gold 22. Raven 21. Ted Kord 20. Alan Scott 19. Aquaman 18. She-Hulk 17.Cyclops 16. Hank Pym 15. Thing (Ben Grimm) 14. Green Arrow (Oliver Queen) 13. Power Girl 12. Iron Man 11. Captain America 10. Robin (Tim Drake) 9. Nightwing (Dick Grayson) 8. The Spectre 7. Martian Manhunter 6. Barry Allen (Flash) 5. Wonder Woman 4. Spider-Man 3. Captain Marvel 2. Batman 1. Superman
Explanation: Here's where my true colors shine through.....I'm an unabashed DC fanboy. I may like Marvel, and read both company's books.......but I personally LOVE DC heroes. "Why No Wolverine?".......because honestly Wolverine has NEVER sold me on a comic, I don't hate him, but i think he's gotten a bit like Batman, he gets shoehorned in and elevated over an entire spectrum of heroes.
|
|
|
Post by Joker on Mar 20, 2012 3:58:37 GMT -5
C'mon now I know there are more comic book fans on here, let's see your votes.
|
|
Big Bad Brad
Wade Wilson
Big Bad Brad
Tournament Master
Posts: 27,409
|
Post by Big Bad Brad on Mar 20, 2012 5:29:34 GMT -5
Super Heros 1. Spiderman 2. Batman 3. Apache Chief 4. Deadpool 5. Incredible Hulk 6. Wolverine 7. Captain America 8. The Flash 9. The Thing 10. Superman 11. Wonder Woman 12. Cyclops 13. Gambit 14. Mr. Fantastic 15. Human Torch 16. Invisible Woman 17. Batgirl 18. The Tick 19. Storm 20. The Beast 21. Iron Man 22. Rogue 23. She-Hulk 24. Captain Marvel 25. Green Lantern 26. Hellboy 27. Aquaman 28. Silver Surfer 29. Jubilee 30. Robin
Super Villains 1. Joker 2. Magneto 3. Cat Woman 4. Bizarro 5. Two-Face 6. Scarecrow 7. The Penguin 8. Lex Luthor 9. Harley Quinn 10. Green Goblin 11. Venom 12. Doomsday 13. Poison Ivy 14. Deathstroke 15. Riddler 16. Mr. Freeze 17. The Mad Hatter 18. Chameleon 19. Punisher 20. Kingpin 21. Mr Sinister 22. Carnage 23. Doctor Octopus 24. Mysterio 25. Mystique 26. Bane 27. Darkseid 28. Juggernaut 29. Brainiac 30. The Blob
|
|
|
Post by Loki-A-Go-Go! on Mar 20, 2012 9:07:50 GMT -5
8. The Flash 17. Batgirl 24. Captain Marvel 25. Green Lantern 30. Robin 10. Green Goblin 11. Venom 24. Mysterio You have to list which version since there have been multiple people to be these characters.
|
|
Big Bad Brad
Wade Wilson
Big Bad Brad
Tournament Master
Posts: 27,409
|
Post by Big Bad Brad on Mar 20, 2012 15:02:08 GMT -5
8. The Flash 17. Batgirl 24. Captain Marvel 25. Green Lantern 30. Robin 10. Green Goblin 11. Venom 24. Mysterio You have to list which version since there have been multiple people to be these characters. Any version would work if its ok could you just pick one for each at random.
|
|