(Another) WWE Mafia Game! {Game Over!}

[lodirulz]

Jan 22, 2014 16:13:38 GMT -5 Waffel113 said:

Well each Shield member has been a bodyguard so far. Assuming AH is telling the truth and he is Dean Ambrose, is it that farfetched that he's a bodyguard as well?

It's possible, I mean, there's two types of Bodyguards: A Regular Bodyguard, and what Roman Reigns was, an Elite Bodyguard.

When Seth Rollins died, it said Backup Bodyguard, not Backup Elite Bodyguard.

And it does fits The Shield's positions:

Reigns is the star of the group, (Elite)
Rollins is considered the weak link, (Backup)
And Ambrose is in between. (Regular)

[pegasuswarrior]

Ok

Legit question:

This makes sense to me. (I really wished we hadn't seen that "things got interesting" during the night action comment that Anon GM made, because it causing me to think "how crazy did it get exactly?") COULD it be that Kofi (ritt) was on his way to protect. It says that as he was about to attempt his protection, he was met with the thump of a blunt instrument. Before??? So, if the doctor plus tracker plus bus driver thing went off, is it possible AH is telling the truth and RITT HIMSELF was the one whacked last night. Read it again. I would've never caught it if I didn't go back.

Here is where I am fearful. Because of the info presented, I've drawn a line in the sand against AH. AH's claim seems like it would be counterintuitive to lie about as scum. Now, either AH is lying and trying to buy one more day for numbers purposes OR it's possible ritt was killed outright. So if I go out, when the flip shows Town, AH is obviously next. If AH is right (which I really want to believe) we may have missed the fact the ritt was whacked outright.

The level of p***** that I would be to have another victory fall through the cracks after such a good start would be historic.

[The Legend]

Jan 22, 2014 18:27:07 GMT -5 pegasuswarrior said:

Ok

Legit question:

This makes sense to me. (I really wished we hadn't seen that "things got interesting" during the night action comment that Anon GM made, because it causing me to think "how crazy did it get exactly?") COULD it be that Kofi (ritt) was on his way to protect. It says that as he was about to attempt his protection, he was met with the thump of a blunt instrument. Before??? So, if the doctor plus tracker plus bus driver thing went off, is it possible AH is telling the truth and RITT HIMSELF was the one whacked last night. Read it again. I would've never caught it if I didn't go back.

Here is where I am fearful. Because of the info presented, I've drawn a line in the sand against AH. AH's claim seems like it would be counterintuitive to lie about as scum. Now, either AH is lying and trying to buy one more day for numbers purposes OR it's possible ritt was killed outright. So if I go out, when the flip shows Town, AH is obviously next. If AH is right (which I really want to believe) we may have missed the fact the ritt was whacked outright.

The level of p***** that I would be to have another victory fall through the cracks after such a good start would be historic.

Sloth should of still seen ritt go visit AH rather than you...

[pegasuswarrior]

Jan 22, 2014 18:34:32 GMT -5 The Legend said:

Jan 22, 2014 18:27:07 GMT -5 pegasuswarrior said:

Ok

Legit question:

This makes sense to me. (I really wished we hadn't seen that "things got interesting" during the night action comment that Anon GM made, because it causing me to think "how crazy did it get exactly?") COULD it be that Kofi (ritt) was on his way to protect. It says that as he was about to attempt his protection, he was met with the thump of a blunt instrument. Before??? So, if the doctor plus tracker plus bus driver thing went off, is it possible AH is telling the truth and RITT HIMSELF was the one whacked last night. Read it again. I would've never caught it if I didn't go back.

Here is where I am fearful. Because of the info presented, I've drawn a line in the sand against AH. AH's claim seems like it would be counterintuitive to lie about as scum. Now, either AH is lying and trying to buy one more day for numbers purposes OR it's possible ritt was killed outright. So if I go out, when the flip shows Town, AH is obviously next. If AH is right (which I really want to believe) we may have missed the fact the ritt was whacked outright.

The level of p***** that I would be to have another victory fall through the cracks after such a good start would be historic.

Sloth should of still seen ritt go visit AH rather than you...

Exactly why AH's recent revelation has me questioning what I originally set up (via Tyger). If ritt was trying to protect me, Spartan saw that, but I changed spots with AH. I can't figure why Spartan saw ritt visit, yet AH still be Town. Does the tracker see actual contact or does the tracker see their target "enter the locker room of --blank--?" Based on the hard evidence I have (me town, me bus driver switch with AH, ritt doctor visit, Spartan tracking Rory's movement) it points to AH. What my question is, could AH be telling the truth and Spartan DID see ritt enter the office/locker room and also be the one killed directly by the night kill. Certainly seems as if it's plausible based on the write-up AND the fact that Spartan is a Tracker, not a Voyeur or whatever the role is called that allows one to see what HAPPENS to their target.

Where is some of peeps who haven't posted? We know there has to be a bodyguard since the backup died. No one will counterclaim? I say AH may be right. I'm starting to wonder if that ritt death was the complicated part that led to the "interesting" comment that our game mod made. I would imagine it would have been a tough write-up to manage if it played out like that.

[pegasuswarrior]

Rory = ritt. Phone autocorrect from above.

[MrBRulzOK]

Alright... let me get this straight. So far these roles have all been hinted at/claimed by various people.

Hawkeye: Innocent Child
Spartan: Tracker
Senor Tyger: Cop/Investigator
Artificial Human: Bodyguard
Pegasus: Jack of All Trades
Waffel: Roleblocker
DarkMyau: Mason

Interesting that so many people have decided to lay their proverbial cards out on the table.

Now of the various roles, here are the ones I can buy no questions asked.

Roleblocker, well we haven't seen one confirmed on the Mafia side. If Waffel is truly faking a claim then it'll be revealed the later this game progresses. So I can buy him for now.

Tyger investigated Mason and hinted that he was town earlier in the game. This pretty much confirms he's on the town's side barring some ridiculous luck.

Hawkeye is one-hundred percent guaranteed town. No disputing the innocent child, obviously.

That leaves Artificial, Spartan, and Pegasus.

And come to think of it, Spartan claimed that he tracked CH one night who visited Waffel. If AH were claiming he was a bodyguard, then no doubt CH could easily counterclaim. Yet he hasn't as of yet.

So... taking all that into account, I have to wonder that maybe AH is legit the third bodyguard? Spartan would be have to be pretty darn crafty to get away with lying about CH visiting Waffel.

Essentially taking all this into consideration, I have no earthly idea who to take a closer look at.

So the question is... what exactly do we do now?

[Deleted]

Innocent child?

Every time I think I am starting to understand this game, someone throws out a new role...Whats next :S

And also

VOTE Anon GM is Hornswaggle pretending to be Bad News Barrett

[Waffel113]

Voting for the GM to be lynched? Gutsy move there kid .

[pegasuswarrior]

Unvote

I buy it. I just buy it. The ritt situation confounds me to no end. I thought the chain of events had AH nailed to the wall. I felt as good about myself as at any point in any game, but the AH claim adds up (there are certainly safe fake claims he could have made). It goes back to that write-up. Something is amiss, and if it's something beyond the fact that ritt was tracked (the Tracker would be able to see ritt go into a player's locker room or office) but night-killed as the actual target, then I'm just not seeing it. The head-scratcher for me is that it seems as if any night-killer would've gotten to ritt before he had a chance to visit a locker room or office. I do not know why the Kofi situation was given that amount of attention in the write-up if there wasn't something more significant than a simple night-kill targeting ritt. At this stage, it's the only thing I can come up with, barring any counterclaim to Artificial Human's role. But I buy it.

Jan 20, 2014 17:05:34 GMT -5 pegasuswarrior said:

Safelist entering Night 3:

Waffel
B Natural
Double H
Lodirulz
Mason (now deceased)
Casey Jones
SNS
Jazzman
Tyger

Simply by process of elimination, that leaves me (left me) with the following left to choose from:

Shiro
WCW Champion Dark something (I guess this is Dark Torgeddon)
Artificial Human
Sloth Spartan
Hawk Jefferson
CH Punk
ritt (now deceased)

Any of the “safelist” outside of confirmed roleclaims could be Serial Killer, I suppose. So, the above list is more of a “hunt for Mafia” type of scenario. Out of those non-safelist people, I’ve actually toyed with the idea of Spartan being more on the “safe list” than the rest of them. That premise was based solely on how hard he was playing it on Day One. Just seemed a little too much Town effort for someone in a Mafia role at that time.

I posted this a couple of pages ago when trying to rationalize who would make a good target. Last night, I felt Artificial Human was as good a target as any. No evidence to support why he'd be Town, and I took the gamble.

So, over the course of three/four pages, Artificial Human, Sloth Spartan, and Hawk are in the clear.

Who's left?

Shiro
Dark Torgaddon
CH Punk

#Progress

Night actions, it would appear, turned into a confusing cluster-eff, but looking back, at least this much has come out of it. The shortlist for me is ... quite short now.

[pegasuswarrior]

Jan 22, 2014 21:46:23 GMT -5 pegasuswarrior said:

Unvote

I buy it. I just buy it. The ritt situation confounds me to no end. I thought the chain of events had AH nailed to the wall. I felt as good about myself as at any point in any game, but the AH claim adds up (there are certainly safe fake claims he could have made). It goes back to that write-up. Something is amiss, and if it's something beyond the fact that ritt was tracked (the Tracker would be able to see ritt go into a player's locker room or office) but night-killed as the actual target, then I'm just not seeing it. The head-scratcher for me is that it seems as if any night-killer would've gotten to ritt before he had a chance to visit a locker room or office. I do not know why the Kofi situation was given that amount of attention in the write-up if there wasn't something more significant than a simple night-kill targeting ritt. At this stage, it's the only thing I can come up with, barring any counterclaim to Artificial Human's role. But I buy it.

Jan 20, 2014 17:05:34 GMT -5 pegasuswarrior said:

Safelist entering Night 3:

Waffel
B Natural
Double H
Lodirulz
Mason (now deceased)
Casey Jones
SNS
Jazzman
Tyger

Simply by process of elimination, that leaves me (left me) with the following left to choose from:

Shiro
WCW Champion Dark something (I guess this is Dark Torgeddon)
Artificial Human
Sloth Spartan
Hawk Jefferson
CH Punk
ritt (now deceased)

Any of the “safelist” outside of confirmed roleclaims could be Serial Killer, I suppose. So, the above list is more of a “hunt for Mafia” type of scenario. Out of those non-safelist people, I’ve actually toyed with the idea of Spartan being more on the “safe list” than the rest of them. That premise was based solely on how hard he was playing it on Day One. Just seemed a little too much Town effort for someone in a Mafia role at that time.

I posted this a couple of pages ago when trying to rationalize who would make a good target. Last night, I felt Artificial Human was as good a target as any. No evidence to support why he'd be Town, and I took the gamble.

So, over the course of three/four pages, Artificial Human, Sloth Spartan, and Hawk are in the clear.

Who's left?

Shiro
Dark Torgaddon
CH Punk

#Progress

Night actions, it would appear, turned into a confusing cluster-eff, but looking back, at least this much has come out of it. The shortlist for me is ... quite short now.

Torgaddon is the 2nd half of the Masonry. My bad. I forgot to remove him.

Shiro and/or CH Punk.

#MajorProgress

Both have voted for me despite the evidence.

Good enough for me, as I figure there are still two active Mafia members running around.

Vote: CH Punk

Either one works for me.

[Deleted]

Jan 22, 2014 6:07:37 GMT -5 @torgaddon said:

Jan 21, 2014 8:43:07 GMT -5 CH Punk said:

Is there something you know that we don't?

Did you really think Anon would put a beginner by himself in his first game of mafia? Of course not. Josh had help from the other mafia and I had help from Mason. I have pretty much been following instructions since day 1. So now for the first time I am on my own here. It's actually kinda weird lol.

Not that I'm attacking that claim but the roles, as far as we know, were assigned at <3 random <3 by Anonymous GM. It's my first game too and it hasn't been easy for me at all.

We know not to read into the write-up too much but double check Ambrose's description during Reign's write-up. Sounds like he could, emphasis on could, be the serial killer:

"Roman Reigns himself even felt a bit paranoid at his demented looking partner, snorting the air and looking indifferent beside him."

[Allison Reynolds]

Message from the GM - And I Quote: Roles are randomized.

---

VOTE COUNT!

pegasuswarrior (4) - The Legend, Hawk Hart, Waffel113, CH Punk
Mochi Lone Wolf (1) - @torgaddon
CH Punk (1) - pegasuswarrior

Not Voting:
Mochi Lone Wolf
Brandon Walsh is Insane.
lodirulz
TOO SWEET
MrBRulzOK
@irontyger
Triple H buried SnS
Jazzman
Dub H *

* ==> Not Yet Posted.

If you do not post AT ALL during the day phase. You will be INACTIVE KILLED. (Unless we can replace you somehow).

There are 15 of you left, which means it will take 8 votes to lynch!
Deadline for a lynch is Monday Night, January 27th, after Monday Night RAW! (HST).

[Deleted]

At the moment there is way too many role claims.. *in Sideshow Bob voice* I am aware that I role claimed too so don't bother pointing that out.

So I am a bit confused. SO to play it safe while I do..yet another re read lol.

UNVOTE

VOTE JAZZMAN. Your just too inactive bro and I think you are hiding something, but I will probably change this.

[MrBRulzOK]

I agree. CH has given me an uneasy feeling for awhile, but I couldn't put my finger on exactly why that was. I think it's high time we found out.

Vote: CH Punk

[TOO SWEET]

Right this second, I like the CH option a lot more than Peg or AH. But I'd like to give him a chance to respond before placing my vote on him.

[CH Punk]

Jan 22, 2014 23:29:18 GMT -5 TOO SWEET said:

Right this second, I like the CH option a lot more than Peg or AH. But I'd like to give him a chance to respond before placing my vote on him.

I thought we were cool

Seriously though, I don't know why this is a better idea. This entire day phase has been focused on one man and one man only: Pegasuswarrior. Every other discovery this day has been in part due to his antics (pushing Hawk to reveal his role as Innocent Child and numerous other roleclaims (which he supposedly hates)). Finding out what he truly is would clear a lot of confusion up.

And, looking at his track record, following Peg has been a fruitless endeavour:
- Day 1: No vote.
- Day 2: While he did vote for Wolf, he was nearly forced into doing so (being one of the last people to vote for him and being very, very open to hearing his defence).
- Day 3: Leads the charge on Orange, flips town.

Also, I don't get why some of you are so keen on following everything Peg says to the letter for two reasons. One, in my experience, one of the main forces of the scum hunt flips town (they can have as brilliant of an argument as you can have to get a lynch on someone and, when we ended up following them, surprise, they flipped town) and this nearly blind following of his words worries me a lot. Two, he's our main suspect right now and his alibi is starting to crack, having to change positions on players to never really explaining loose ends about what happened during the night.

Finally, before I get some rest for the night (and I should be able to answer questions tomorrow and that's guaranteed to happen during the weekend), I am more than willing to get lynched if this proves this wild goose chase is leading nowhere.

[TOO SWEET]

Well CH, I've played my cards so there is nothing for me to hide, so I need to go back to our previous conversation.

Jan 9, 2014 14:42:10 GMT -5 CH Punk said:

Jan 9, 2014 2:04:09 GMT -5 TOO SWEET said:

1) Why should I trust you? ...in relation to your what you did recently.
2) If not Zach, who would it have been? ...in relation to your what you did recently.
3) Have you been like Lance Action spreading the love around, or like Richie and AJ, and been committed to one person? ...in relation to your what you did recently.

Oh, I get where you're coming from now.

1) I hope you get this, but if you're like Triple H, then I'm like Brie Bella.
2) The Crazy One's ex-best friend.
3) More like Raj.

I hope we're on the same wavelength when it comes to what's going on.

Triple H, Brie Bella. Later on, because I wasn't entirely sure what that meant, you said Roman/Kofi. For those who don't know the relationship in our e-fed, Brie Bella imitated and mimic'ed Triple H, while Kofi and Roman were tag team partners. I didn't understand what sort of role you were saying you had, but I thought you were claiming to be a bodyguard. Seth and Roman were already gone and bodyguards so I figured you were pretty much saying you were Dean and a bodyguard too. Now that role/character has been claimed.

So what the heck did you do to Waffel on Night Phase Two?

[TOO SWEET]

EBWOP: Maybe bodyguard isn't the right word, but I figured it was some sort of partnership/linked role.

[Dub H]

I'm here,i'm queer.I mena,i'm not.

Anyway,i lsot a bunch of stuff.I know it is m duty but can it would be nice to get a PM when ti starts.

Anyway,from what i saw froma quick look,there is a bunch of roleclaims.Just be careful with the Mason one,there is no way to prove and there is always a chance to have a Mafia as a Mason.

Also Pegasus,why i'm on our safelist .I hardly been a town examples these couple of days.I haven't doing anythign scummy but i also don't think i showed any reason why i am for sure town.

[Jazzman]

Jan 22, 2014 23:05:44 GMT -5 @torgaddon said:

At the moment there is way too many role claims.. *in Sideshow Bob voice* I am aware that I role claimed too so don't bother pointing that out.

So I am a bit confused. SO to play it safe while I do..yet another re read lol.

UNVOTE

VOTE JAZZMAN. Your just too inactive bro and I think you are hiding something, but I will probably change this.

So your play right now is to place a vote against me, someone with nothing to hide because of how out front I played that you feel likely of changing? So let's see, kinda scummy vibe, voting without any sort of conviction and admitting that you'll go along with the crowd. I don't like it but if I'm your target... well so be it.