If Shawn Michaels is Mr. WrestleMania...

[evilone]

There is no more inappropriate nickname in WWE than Mr. Wrestlemania for Shawn Michaels.

[The Heartbreak TWERK]

Can we call Roman Reigns Mr. Royal Rumble Ruiner?

We could even call him Quadruple R, Hunter will love it!

[A Platypus Rave is Correct]

Jan 5, 2018 1:36:39 GMT -5 DiBiase is Good said:

Survivor Series is forever associated with The Undertaker for me. So I’d have to say he is Mr. Survivor Series.

Yeah, Taker is Survivor Series to me too.

[Savage Facepalm]

I thought Roman Reigns now holds the record for the most eliminations in a single royal rumble, or am I wrong about this? My pick for Mr. Royal Rumble would have to be Austin (no way to argue against the 3 wins).

Mr. Wrestlemania is Shawn Michaels (with Undertaker and Hogan just slightly behind).

For Mr. SummerSlam, it's pretty much a toss up between Brock and Bret (either one is a great choice).

As for Mr. Survivor Series, I would go with either Undertaker or Orton for reasons everybody already stated.

[chazraps]

I think you could make a sleeper argument for Christian as Mr. Summerslam.

1999 - standout performance in tag team turmoil
2000 - TLC
2001 - seeds planted for Edge-Christian breakup
2002 - The Un-Americans (Christian and Lance Storm) (c) defeated Booker T and Goldust
2009 - ECW title: Christian (c) defeated William Regal ( in eight seconds)
2011 - No Holds Barred World Title: Randy Orton defeated Christian
2013 - World Title last chance match: Alberto Del Rio (c) defeated Christian by submission

[Juice]

I have thread dejuvu i swear this exact thread and responses existed before

[Cranjis McBasketball]

Jan 5, 2018 7:49:11 GMT -5 thecrusherwi said:

I always thought it was weird that the announcers and even Shawn himself bought into the Mr Wrestlemania moniker in kayfabe. He was 6-11 at Wrestlemania. Why are you bragging about it? Because your matches were exciting and your loses were memorable? I guess Lebron James is Mr NBA Finals by that logic.

Not to mention over half those matches are in no way memorable or the best on the show.

[Deleted]

Jan 5, 2018 1:46:55 GMT -5 OVO 40 hunched over like he 80 said:

Stevie Richards would be Mr Sunday Night Heat.

I'll show myself out.

I love how the Stevie Night Heat stuff (at least according to Stevie) lasted as long as it did because Vince and Steph didn't watch Heat.

[Big DSR Energy]

Jan 5, 2018 18:49:03 GMT -5 Juice said:

I have thread dejuvu i swear this exact thread and responses existed before

I know we've had this thread come up in the past.

[Susan "Poison" Candy]

• Mr. New Year’s Revolution:
• Mr. Royal Rumble:
• Mr. No Way Out:
• Mr. Elimination Chamber:
• Mr. Fast Lane:
• Mr. Wrestlemania:
• Mr. Backlash:
• Mr. Extreme Rules:
• Mr. Judgment Day:
• Mr. Bad Blood:
• Mr. Payback:
• Mr. King of the Ring:
• Mr. In Your House:
• Mr. One Night Stand:
• Mr. Money in the Bank:
• Mr. Over The Edge:
• Mr. Insurrextion:
• Mr. Fully Loaded:
• Mr. Capital Punishment:
• Mr. Fatal 4 Way:
• Mr. Invasion:
• Mr. Vengeance:
• Mr. Great American Bash:
• Mr. Great Balls of Fire:
• Mr. Over The Limit:
• Mr. Battleground:
• Mr. Summerslam:
• Mr. Unforgiven:
• Mr. Breaking Point:
• Mr. Night of Champions:
• Mr. No Mercy:
• Mr. Hell in a Cell:
• Mr. Bragging Rights:
• Mr. Rebellion:
• Mr. Cyber Sunday:
• Mr. Surivor Series:
• Mr. Armageddon:
• Mr. Tables, Ladders, & Chairs:
• Mr. Clash of Champions:
• Mr. December to Dismember:

[thecrusherwi]

As fast as I could off the top of my head

Jan 5, 2018 19:30:58 GMT -5 Susan "Poison" Candy said:

Mr. New Year’s Revolution: Edge
Mr. Royal Rumble: Kane
Mr. No Way Out: Eddie Guerrero
Mr. Elimination Chamber: Triple H
Mr. Fast Lane: Roman Reigns
Mr. Wrestlemania: Shawn Michaels
Mr. Backlash: The Rock
Mr. Extreme Rules: Osama Bin Laden
Mr. Judgment Day: JBL
Mr. Bad Blood: Mae Young
Mr. Payback: Seth Rollins
Mr. King of the Ring: Bret Hart
Mr. In Your House: Diesel
Mr. One Night Stand: RVD
Mr. Money in the Bank: CM Punk
Mr. Over The Edge: ……………….Dude Love
Mr. Insurrextion: Shane McMahon
Mr. Fully Loaded: Sable
Mr. Capital Punishment: R-Truth
Mr. Fatal 4 Way: Maryse
Mr. Invasion: A Face that’s Half Vince Half Shane
Mr. Vengeance: Kurt Angle
Mr. Great American Bash: Dusty Rhodes
Mr. Great Balls of Fire: Brock Lesnar
Mr. Over The Limit: Randy Orton for injuring himself during his taunt
Mr. Battleground: Ryback
Mr. Summerslam: Randy Savage
Mr. Unforgiven: Inferno Match
Mr. Breaking Point: Handcuffs
Mr. Night of Champions: The Entrance with all the Belts
Mr. No Mercy: Naked Mideon
Mr. Hell in a Cell: Shawn Michaels again
Mr. Bragging Rights: The Miz
Mr. Rebellion: British Bulldog Throwing a Trash Can
Mr. Cyber Sunday: King Bookah
Mr. Surivor Series: Undertaker
Mr. Armageddon: The Kat
Mr. Tables, Ladders, & Chairs: The Shield
Mr. Clash of Champions: Ric Flair
Mr. December to Dismember: The Sandman

[atgnatpodcast]

I would argue that Hogan is Mr Wrestlemania...
He Was a part of the main event for the first 9 (interfered at IV) and had an awesome nostalgia moment at WM 18.

[J is Justice]

For me, I think Shawn is Mr. Royal Rumble, too, just because they always went on about how difficult it was to eliminate him. Plus, he won two of them.

[Woo]

Bret Hart is Mr Summerslam. Bulldog, Bulldog, Owen, Taker, the tag matches. All excellent. Angle is another people are sleeping on here. In the main event at 2000,Austin in 01,Rey at 02,Lesnar at 03

Mr Rumble might be Foley.

SSeries, yeah Orton works.

[Hulk With A Mustache]

Jan 5, 2018 19:30:58 GMT -5 Susan "Poison" Candy said:

• Mr. New Year’s Revolution:
• Mr. Royal Rumble:
• Mr. No Way Out:
• Mr. Elimination Chamber:
• Mr. Fast Lane:
• Mr. Wrestlemania:
• Mr. Backlash:
• Mr. Extreme Rules:
• Mr. Judgment Day:
• Mr. Bad Blood:
• Mr. Payback:
• Mr. King of the Ring:
• Mr. In Your House:
• Mr. One Night Stand:
• Mr. Money in the Bank:
• Mr. Over The Edge:
• Mr. Insurrextion:
• Mr. Fully Loaded:
• Mr. Capital Punishment:
• Mr. Fatal 4 Way:
• Mr. Invasion:
• Mr. Vengeance:
• Mr. Great American Bash:
• Mr. Great Balls of Fire:
• Mr. Over The Limit:
• Mr. Battleground:
• Mr. Summerslam:
• Mr. Unforgiven:
• Mr. Breaking Point:
• Mr. Night of Champions:
• Mr. No Mercy:
• Mr. Hell in a Cell:
• Mr. Bragging Rights:
• Mr. Rebellion:
• Mr. Cyber Sunday:
• Mr. Surivor Series:
• Mr. Armageddon:
• Mr. Tables, Ladders, & Chairs:
• Mr. Clash of Champions:
• Mr. December to Dismember:

You forgot The Wrestling Classic and Capital Carnage.

[unc40]

Jan 5, 2018 18:55:30 GMT -5 Cranjis McBasketball said:

Jan 5, 2018 7:49:11 GMT -5 thecrusherwi said:

I always thought it was weird that the announcers and even Shawn himself bought into the Mr Wrestlemania moniker in kayfabe. He was 6-11 at Wrestlemania. Why are you bragging about it? Because your matches were exciting and your loses were memorable? I guess Lebron James is Mr NBA Finals by that logic.

Not to mention over half those matches are in no way memorable or the best on the show.

The Undertaker should be Mr. Wrestlemania after all he is 23-2 and defeated Shawn Michaels twice at the event. Who even said Shawn's matches were the best in the show? Oh wait, Shawn said they were great matches. Then it must be true.

[Deleted]

Is Jimmy Uso Mr. Wrestlemania Pre-Show?

[mcstoklasa]

Jan 5, 2018 22:33:31 GMT -5 atgnatpodcast said:

I would argue that Hogan is Mr Wrestlemania...
He Was a part of the main event for the first 9 (interfered at IV) and had an awesome nostalgia moment at WM 18.

WM19 was pretty great for him too

[mizerable]

Jan 5, 2018 16:03:36 GMT -5 evilone said:

There is no more inappropriate nickname in WWE than Mr. Wrestlemania for Shawn Michaels.

Heartbreak Kid while over 40 and balding?
The Showstopper when they never stopped the show?
The Main Event when he wasn't always the main event?
The Headliner when he didn't always headline?
The Icon? What is he, Sting?

[Alice Syndrome]

Jan 5, 2018 9:26:19 GMT -5 Lt. Palumbo said:

Jan 5, 2018 0:53:43 GMT -5 The Thread Barbi said:

Mr Survivor Series - Ultimate Warrior?

Sure Orton has the edge having competed in more events but Warrior is undefeated at the event and a sole survivor three times.

Mr. Wrestlemania isn't Shawn Michaels in my eyes. It's the Undertaker.

This raises the point I wanted to make. If we're using Shawn as the template then undefeatedness is not the main criterion for the Mr. PPV title, it's memorable performances.

If that's one of the key criteria then Mr. Royal Rumble is Austin or Kane for me

Then Mr Royal Rumble is Kofi