Rate Survivor Series 2023

[Lizuka #BLM]

Well I know what I'm going with.

[ejm olmos]

That’s a 10 for me, Jeff. Holy shit.

[chronocross]

I enjoyed the card overall and the ending with Randy's big return and then on top of that CM Punk coming back was shocking.

10/10.

[Captain Stud Muffin (BLM)]

9 out of 10

Every match slapped

2 legends returning

[BigPoppaNasty]

Gotta get a 10 when you have the moment of the year in all of professional wrestling.

[UN PLOMBIER NIGHTMARE #blm]

As much as I wanna hit that f*** cm punk vote cause I didn’t wanna see him back, I gotta give this show a 9. The grand majority of it was predictable and it was still an amazing show.

[The Gallus Mark]

Even with Punk being Punk, that was still about the happiest that they could’ve sent the Chicago crowd home

10. Loved seeing Randy back and looking big as shit lol

[deezy]

Easy 10. Especially with punk at the end.

[Gus Richlen: Ruffian]

A 9 until Punk showed up. Now it's a middle finger.

[Allie Kitsune]

Nov 25, 2023 22:54:40 GMT -5 UN PLOMBIER NIGHTMARE #blm said:

As much as I wanna hit that f*** cm punk vote cause I didn’t wanna see him back, I gotta give this show a 9. The grand majority of it was predictable and it was still an amazing show.

I'm going with a 9 because it felt like the main roster putting on a classic Black-and-Gold Takeover show.

It loses a point for the stench of Phil writhing its way back in.

[J is Justice]

I've gotta go 10. Worst match was Rhea versus Zoe and it still wasn't bad. Best match was the Women's War Games match.

[Fade]

that was one of the greatest wrestling things I’ve ever experienced I wanna preface and say I have my issues with the guy but the womens WarGames stealing the show, every match slapping, lit crowd, one of my favorites (Randy ..and r truth) returning and that shocker end…10.

Holidays are bad for me. really needed and looked forward to this PLE. Can not have predicted how insane of a moment it would be.

Holy shit 10.

[Ben Wyatt]

High 9.

Damn good show

[asuka007]

9/10:

The Women’s WG match was easily MOTN. I get why Damage CTRL lost, but I just wish it wasn’t their first big match and Kairi’s first match back.

Gunther vs. Miz and Santos vs. Dragon Lee were fun.

Rhea vs. Zoey was decent, but Rhea feels so much bigger as a star than almost every other woman that it’s hard got her opponents to work face against her.

The Men’s WG Match was, fine. But aside from Randy’s return it was nowhere near ad good as the Women’s Match.

[Jindrak Mark]

The 3 middle matches were kinda key. I expected both war games matches to be great but if the crowd was dead for the middle matches like I thought they might be it could have brought the show down quite a bit. Luckily the Chicago crowd was great though. I personally didn't care for Rhea/Zoey but enjoyed Gunther/Miz and Santos/Dragon Lee more than I expected.

I don't think Becky and Cody getting the pinfalls in their matches was random. They seem to be postioned as the babyface challengers for Rhea and Roman at Mania.

The last 20-30 minutes of the PPV were insane. The babyfaces are so over right now. That pop for Orton and how stacked that face side was then obviously ending with Punk.

[fw91]

8 for the ending and war games, but the rest of it, albeit not bad in-ring at all, didn't really grasp my attention.

[hashtagdaley/JudasDay]

10est 10 that ever 10’d

[Some Baritone guy IS REDEEMED!]

Nov 25, 2023 22:56:31 GMT -5 Gus Richlen: Ruffian said:

A 9 until Punk showed up. Now it's a middle finger.

Did not know you hated Punk.

[clc]

7

Women's War Games was a great match with bad story telling. They built the whole thing around Charlotte and Becky. They realized they are actually super besties becasue they are so good at beating up Damage CTRL. None of Damage CTRL's story was present in that match. They all got along splendidly. I guess they can retroactively create a story, but it sure was not there in that ring tonight.
Asuka's mist becoming worthless was really annoying. Not just this match but both Charlotte and Bianca basically no-sold it when they got misted. Now freaking Shotzi no-sells it. Arggghh!
Resolving the Becky Charlotte tension after one day. Well, I guess this frees up Charlotte for a title feud! Yay...not.

Gunther vs Miz was amazing and did nothing wrong. Best match of the night.

I was looking forward to Carlito vs Santos. I did not care about Dragon Lee vs Santos. It was a good match, but I was not invested in it at all.

I don't care any bit about over-pushed, overprotected, never gets her comeuppance OP Rhea and I sure as heck don't care about Zoey Stark. To their credit the match was alright. I just was not invested in it at all.

Men's War Games. By this time I'm worn out, and I'm not all that into Judgement Day. The match did not grab my attention until Drew entered. Then it lost me until Randy. The cash in fake-out was kind of annoying.

CM Punk was there. I guess this was cool in a surprise sort of way, but I'm not a huge fan of Punk.


All of my gripes about War Games stand. As a "feud blow-off" War Games sucks. Damage CTRL will still be feuding with Bianca and friends becasue they are the only heels around, and rather than further any story in the match they went with faces win lol. Cody and friends will still feud with Judgement Day for the same reason. This PPV was mostly filler, no real progression of anything (except for Gunther he can move on).

[bob]

Went from a 10 to F Punk rather quickly