Superman vs. Thor

[Baixo Astral]

I love Thor! But Thorpool is the best!

[Baixo Astral]

Please note - I reserve the right to alter any pro-Supes propaganda to make fun of him, his girly hair, and his dumb speech patterns.

[Kevin Hamilton]

As a guy who loves Superman so much I have the Kingdom Come version of his insignia ( my favorite version of the character) permanently scarred in the flesh of my left arm; I support your pro-Kryptonian, and let's face it pro-DC agenda.

[Sir Woodrow]

Thorpool!

[Mr. Emoticon Man, TF Fan]

Much as I love Thor and dislike Superman, I'm forced to agree that Supes would probably win.

JLA/Avengers was as close to canon as we're ever going to see, and the fact that it was a joint project by both Marvel and DC means it has more validity than hypotheticals among fans - and if the hammer is just a keychain, then it's a keychain that Supes, for all his strength, simply cannot lift without the consent of another.

The exception to this is if Bendis is involved, in which case all bets are off. They'd both probably end up losing to Spiderwoman, or something equally stupid.

[Mister Pigwell]

Jun 24, 2010 6:56:25 GMT -5 Sir Woodrow said:

supes.

Thou art quoted for everlasting glory to Asgard... Thor admits the Supe-remacy.

[CMWaters]

Um...everyone's forgetting this, so I may as well make mention of this.

Superman's weaknesses are not only Kryptonite. He's also got the red sun thing and, more importantly in this arguement...MAGIC.

Yes, Superman is weak to Magic. He has little to no defense against it. That's how Ed Boon explained why Superman could be beaten at times in Mortal Kombat vs. DC Universe. That's why Captain Marvel most of the time can beat Superman. Superman is weak to magic.

...that said I do think Superman would win, but it wouldn't be a one sided affair. It may be closer to the Superman/Darkseid fights than it would be Superman vs. an ant.

[Mister Pigwell]

Dammit Spike!

[Maidpool w/ Cleaning Action]

Hey thanks Spike. Not much people think I can win between these two guys, but it's nice to see I have a fan.

[Mister Pigwell]

HA!


You damned funny colored name peoples and your hilarious abuses of power.

[Mr. Emoticon Man, TF Fan]

Jun 24, 2010 13:09:14 GMT -5 CMWaters said:

Um...everyone's forgetting this, so I may as well make mention of this.

Superman's weaknesses are not only Kryptonite. He's also got the red sun thing and, more importantly in this arguement...MAGIC.

Yes, Superman is weak to Magic. He has little to no defense against it. That's how Ed Boon explained why Superman could be beaten at times in Mortal Kombat vs. DC Universe. That's why Captain Marvel most of the time can beat Superman. Superman is weak to magic.

...that said I do think Superman would win, but it wouldn't be a one sided affair. It may be closer to the Superman/Darkseid fights than it would be Superman vs. an ant.

I'm not forgetting. It's just that, like you, I think Supes would pull off the win. I know people make the argument that Thor has super-speed, but I just don't see it; and without it, Superman's still got the edge. Thor would put up a better fight than most, but much as I love him I still think he'd lose.

Though, if Thor has possession of the Odin Force when they clash, that might make a difference.

[waluigi]

Do I need to bring out the "Robert, The Sponge of the Straight Trousers" scan again?

Superman.

[Legion]

Of course Superman would win, the craptacularly boring boy scout wins everything always

[Baldobomb-22-OH-MAN!!!]

Jun 24, 2010 7:59:38 GMT -5 Mr. Emoticon Man, TF Fan said:

The exception to this is if Bendis is involved, in which case all bets are off. They'd both probably end up losing to Spiderwoman, or something equally stupid.

and he wonders why they wouldn't let him write Justice Leage ;D

[Mr. Emoticon Man, TF Fan]

Good for DC. If only Marvel had possessed similar wisdom...