Should Big Show be in ECW?

[JMA]

Some people have criticized Big Show being in ECW, while others think he's worked hard and has made the transition well. Should he be in ECW or should he be on one of the other brands?

Keep in mind I'm asking if he should be on the SHOW, not if he should be the champion.

[Joekishi]

hell yes.

Instant credibility to any brand he's on. Plus he's worked harder than most guys in WWE right now. he does fit as the Monster champ who is also the Boss' golden boy.

he works

[JMA]

I'm interested in seeing how this poll turns out. I myself won't be voting as I want to see what everyone else thinks.

[Rick Mad]

I voted no, just because I don't like him there. Has he worked hard? Yes. Has he done everything asked for him and worked a pretty brutal-seeming schedule? Yes. Do his matches entertain me? Very rarely. Does he do anything in ECW that he couldn't just be doing on Raw or Smackdown? Not really (and he's just doing things on Raw and Smackdown anyway!)

[theedge]

More than some of the originals.

[SmarkyMark]

I didn't vote either but I say yes 'cause he works as a great monster heel champion whose experience and long title reign (for these days) lends instabt credibility to a new brand that needs it.

[Deleted]

I think he's been alright so far. Much better than I would have expected to be sure. Once he drops that belt though I don't think there will be much of a place for him, though they'll probably end up moving him back to RAW or SD soon after...

[HoldingBackTalent aka bugz9987]

Hell yes, better than being on RAW feuding with Umaga...

[tmp2005]

I'm gonna say no, not because I don't think he fits in with ECW, but because I really can't stand the Big Show at all. I liked him in WCW as The Giant, but nothing he does in WWE has ever been interesting. He's always looked big, dumb, and goofy. I hate his look, his name, and his weird, throaty voice.

[bigHEADinc]

I've marked for Big Show for awhile now and, let's be honest, he's the only credible person to even challenge for the championship...

And to anybody who brings up Credible or Dreamer as credible champions, keep in mind that Credible was last used as a member of possibly the worst faction ever, X-Factor, and Dreamer was used as a human spit bucket... So they are in no way a credible (pardon the pun) champion, regardless of whether or not people remember them (aside from the fact that, in my opinion, their work inside the ring isn't anything to write home about)...

[4real]

Yes, he's probably the most credible Champion in the WWECW right now.

[Allison Reynolds]

I say yes. He's been playing his role in ECW well.

[Lick Ness Monster]

Yes, very much. Actually one of the bright spots for me in the entire YEAR has been Show's run on ECW, and I'm not even exaggerating. Don't know if that says how good he's been vs. how crappy of a year it's been, but I'll take it.

[nottombosley]

Yes - he has been a strong, credible champ and is a major heel that ECW desperately needs. I think the ECW brand would be a lot worse without him.

EDIT: Unless he went back to feuding with Tommy Dreamer......then he would suck.

[Erik Majorwitz]

4real said:

Yes, he's probably the most credible Champion in the WWECW right now.

That isn't saying much.

[careless]

I asy yes. I really believe he wants to gain acceptance from old ECW fans. He seems to try so hard. The fact that he was the immediate champion hurts him a lot I think. Of course I say this from the outside looking in.