Did he deserve the title? day 26

[darthobiwan]

I'm going to start a new idea, kinda based on Possum's should have been champion polls. The difference is these will be guys who were world champions and you have to decide if they worthy of having the title or not. If not you could give reasons why not and what you have done differently. If yes you can say why they did deserve it or change any other things about their title reign(s).

This isn't about if they should have had as long of reign and/or as many reigns, just if they deserved the title period. I'm going to leave out guys like hogan, flair, austin, and even cena for now since mostly everyone would agree that they deserved the title at least once.

next one is...




Goldberg

***results so far

*Yes
ricky steamboat- 21-0
superstar billy graham- 19-0
eddie guerrero- 26-1
kane- 25-1
iron sheik- 21-1
andre the giant- 19-1
chris jericho- 17-1
buddy rogers- 15-1
ultimate warrior- 21-3
mick foley- 20-3
rob van dam- 22-6
sheamus- 19-6
yokozuna- 16-7
jeff hardy- 17-9
sid- 15-8
jbl- 16-11
lex luger- 12-10
ron simmons- 11-9
antonio inoki- 8-7

*No
ronnie garvin- 16-1
tommy rich- 12-1
vince mcmahon- 16-3
stan stasiak- 9-4
sgt. slaughter- 13-11


*undecided
ivan koloff- 4-4

[saneiac]

Which title? WCW title - absolutely. WWE title - absolutely not.

[Gus Richlen Was Wrong]

i think he earned both: the wcw title because he was built to simply be this truly awesome force tha almost nobody could stop, and the wwe incarnation of the WHC because he honestly looked (at least at the time) to be the most credible threat to triple h and evolution.

[Bake Or Die]

Yes

[bob]

which title: WCW or WWE?

[Incognito]

Regardless of which belt were talking about, I say he deserved it because he was well booked. He had just enough moves, he had awesome charisma and most people bought the fact that he was the irresistable force.

At his height, he was amazing.

[fw91]

absolutely

[Crappler El 0 M]

Yes.

[Malibu Albino]

He deserved both, he was booked incredibly well as this unstoppable force.

[Junkenstein]

Definitely. Pardon the pun, but WCW struck gold with Goldberg. Just a shame they didn't have a f***ing clue what to do with him after he won the title.

[ThePhenomenal620]

Nov 10, 2010 12:34:27 GMT -5 Junkenstein said:

Definitely. Pardon the pun, but WCW struck gold with Goldberg. Just a shame they didn't have a f***ing clue what to do with him after he won the title.

Couldn't agree with you more.

Goldberg deserved both the WCW and WWE World Titles.

[The Possum]

He was one of the best parts of WCW. Definitely.

[darthobiwan]

Just to let everyone know, its if he deserved to be a world champion PERIOD regardless of the company (wwe, wcw, ect.).