Post by TOO SWEET on Oct 20, 2012 2:11:53 GMT -5
I actually do kind of get what you're getting at, Double H. But thinking about the suspects, I'm fairly certain that if either of us vote for Jono, then Brad, Queen Mab, and possibly Producerman are going to jump onto that vote.
And if we vote for Brad/Queen Mab, Jono is defintitely going to jump on.
And with them all being against Producerman, I can't figure out if its a mafia member trying to blend in with the town against one of his own, or trying to secure our failure.
So right now... I have no clue which person we should go for. But I still don't feel that confident about Producerman.
Here's my real problems with him so far.
The other explanations checked out for me. They weren't enough to clear him as town... but at least they felt decently believable. I have a real hard time believing this one though.
An experienced player would know they could unvote. Even besides that, its in the first post. But here's the thing. I mentioned it, because there was one huge thing I was really wanting to see if he would address, but he skirted and hide from the issue.
The real problem is that it wasn't like there was even guilt. Like Mab pointed out, when the lynch started forming, Producerman was all for it and excited. That isn't the actions of a pressure vote, that is the actions of a man who wants an actual person strung up by the end of the day phase.
Now he is acting like he wishes he could've done more to prevent it, but in actuality, he was celebrating as it was going on.
Honestly, I'm starting to feel more and more confident about this game.
I think Producerman and Jono are mafia. And I think Jono has joined the suspicion without placing his vote for Producerman to appear more town like, so when Producerman flips mafia, he can act like he was one of the real big people on town's side.
Honestly, I do have a bit of trust for you Double H, so I'm leaning towards the mafia being Producerman, Jonathan Michaels, and Lodirulz.
I do want to hear some sort of response from someone regarding my post before I vote... because I really don't want to screw this up. Whether you think I'm insane or basically figured it out, a second opinion from someone I believe is town would be really helpful. (so either Double H, Queen Mab, or Kami)
And if we vote for Brad/Queen Mab, Jono is defintitely going to jump on.
And with them all being against Producerman, I can't figure out if its a mafia member trying to blend in with the town against one of his own, or trying to secure our failure.
So right now... I have no clue which person we should go for. But I still don't feel that confident about Producerman.
Here's my real problems with him so far.
B: yes, i was there when the bandwagon on cage king formed and yes I could have unvoted. To be 100% honest, it didn't even occur to me to do so. Maybe it was the lack of playing for two years, maybe it was simply not thinking clearly but I'll be first to admit that I should have done more to stop the bandwagon.
The other explanations checked out for me. They weren't enough to clear him as town... but at least they felt decently believable. I have a real hard time believing this one though.
An experienced player would know they could unvote. Even besides that, its in the first post. But here's the thing. I mentioned it, because there was one huge thing I was really wanting to see if he would address, but he skirted and hide from the issue.
The real problem is that it wasn't like there was even guilt. Like Mab pointed out, when the lynch started forming, Producerman was all for it and excited. That isn't the actions of a pressure vote, that is the actions of a man who wants an actual person strung up by the end of the day phase.
Now he is acting like he wishes he could've done more to prevent it, but in actuality, he was celebrating as it was going on.
Honestly, I'm starting to feel more and more confident about this game.
I think Producerman and Jono are mafia. And I think Jono has joined the suspicion without placing his vote for Producerman to appear more town like, so when Producerman flips mafia, he can act like he was one of the real big people on town's side.
Honestly, I do have a bit of trust for you Double H, so I'm leaning towards the mafia being Producerman, Jonathan Michaels, and Lodirulz.
I do want to hear some sort of response from someone regarding my post before I vote... because I really don't want to screw this up. Whether you think I'm insane or basically figured it out, a second opinion from someone I believe is town would be really helpful. (so either Double H, Queen Mab, or Kami)