Who would've been your favs during times you weren't a fan?

[J is Justice]

Basically, which wrestlers have you looked back on during the times you weren't a fan and thought "they would've been my guy/girl?"

For me, I think I would've been a Dolph Ziggler fan. He gave me Mr. Perfect vibes and I was a huge fan of Mr. Perfect.

I think Becky would've been another. I liked the steampunk aesthetic and she seemed like a goof. Unfortunately, her heel run left a bad taste in my mouth and I'm still recovering, lol.

CM Punk, definitely. I became a fan when he debuted in AEW so I don't see why I wouldn't have been a fan back in the day.

[wildojinx]

Huh, the problem here is I became a fan in 1990 and never really stopped watching. That said, I probably would have loved the Road Warriors if I had started watching earlier (as it was, I enjoyed them, but not as much as Demolition, who I liked, even as heels).

[Allie Kitsune]

I wasn't watching in the 80s, but if I had been, it probably would have been Macho. I know that's kind of a cop-out pick and an easy one, but it is what it is.

[Bo Rida]

The Crusher and Baron von Raschke.

[Mozenrath]

I'd have likely been a Midnight Express fan. Eaton is very fun to watch, and I find Stan Lane's dubious martial arts moves fun.

[Deleted]

I starting watching around 1989 and took my longest break in 1995-1996.
Had I been watching then, it would have probably been HBK.

[Instant Classic]

Macho Man. I didn’t start watching until 2000.

[tafkaga]

Miz. I've been a sporadic fan between 2000-current, never keeping up for more than 3-4 month stretches at a time, but I have always enjoyed Miz.