Rate It: CM Punk vs Elijah Burke at Judgment Day!

[voiceboxisback]

I'd say around a **** 1/4 or ****, not including crowd reaction. The crowd was crap for most of it.

[THE Dinobot]

The crowds are dumb.

It was maybe 'round 3 1/2, wouldn't want to go overboard with the rating.

[Joekishi]

Yeah 3 to 3.5 would be a nice rating, not exactly a match of the year, but very good match none the less

[BD Punk AKA SUSPENDED!]

I didn't see it, so I won't vote. I'll just assume since Punk was in it and it went longer than 15 mins it was a good match.

[leemir]

I give it 2 stars, I see a lot people saying it was great but the crowd ruined it & they didn't help me get into it at all. I was frustrated by the crowd, match didn't look like it flowed so I didn't enjoy it too much. They are my 2 fav WWE wrestlers & the reason I bought the PPV.

[Hiroshi Hase]

I thought the match was so-so, but the crowd didn't exactly help matters out either.

Maybe they'll have a rematch on ECW TV this week in front of a better crowd.

[EJS]

Hehe the poll looks like a middle finger.

[THE Dinobot]

hadesgigas said:

Hehe the poll looks like a middle finger.

Lets hope it stays that way.

[normansmiley]

I thought it was very solid. I thought the execution could have been a bit better and there were a couple of shaky spots. Good match nonetheless.

[Marky Mark]

Who won?

[leemir]

ralphthrobberson said:

Who won?

Punk with a Go2Sleep.

[Tom Selleck]

Elijah Burke vs. C.M. Page, I mean Punk. They went much longer than you'd think, closing in on 17:00. Way too long for these two and this crowd. They laid out a good match but the execution in sports was real bad. Crowd was up for the finish and for some of the big moves, but they were cold most of the way. I think if you're a fan of Punk you'll say it was good, and if you're not, you'll say this match proved beyond any doubt you were right. Lots of near falls. Japanese style, but a not very good Japanese match.

Credit: The Wrestling Observer

[Johnny]

It was a really good match.

[Andrew is Good]

3.5. Second best match of the night though, next to the Hardys/Cade & Murdoch.

[MCCW > IWC*]

Funny how the crowds are dumb when the match involves the IWC* darlings yet, when its Cena, Batista, etc, hated by the IWC*, then it's "The crowd wasn't into it which proves they suck!"

Hypocrites!

[Swarm]

I gave it ****. I really liked the match a lot.

[primetime110]

nadinesbra said:

Funny how the crowds are dumb when the match involves the IWC* darlings yet, when its Cena, Batista, etc, hated by the IWC*, then it's "The crowd wasn't into it which proves they suck!"

Hypocrites!

Thank you. I was thinking the samething.

[axlbucket]

I thought it was an outstanding match and really lived up to my expectations. Burke should have won!

[Hiroshi Hase]

nadinesbra said:

Funny how the crowds are dumb when the match involves the IWC* darlings yet, when its Cena, Batista, etc, hated by the IWC*, then it's "The crowd wasn't into it which proves they suck!"

Hypocrites!

It was like that for Flair/Carlito for the most part as well, apart from tne "Whooos" for the obligatory Flair chop. Crowd was awful.

[Zane]

Gave it four stars simply because while walking down the aisle Punk yelled out "IT'S CLOBBERIN TIME!!!!!"