I'm *really* bored, so I used this as a way to keep myself busy, and made a pretty lengthy list. These are matches from 2000-2014 that I really enjoyed and would rate in that 4-5 star mix. I hope this list is helpful!
2000
{Spoiler}Triple H (c) vs. Cactus Jack - Street Fight - Royal Rumble 2000
Triple H, XPac, and The Radicalz vs. Cactus Jack, The Rock, and Too Cool - Raw 2/7/00
Triple H (c) vs. Cactus Jack - Hell in a Cell - No Way Out 2000
Edge/Christian vs. Hardyz vs. Dudleyz - Ladder Match - WrestleMania 2000
Chris Jericho vs. Triple H - Last Man Standing - Fully Loaded 2000
Edge/Christian vs. Hardyz vs. Dudleyz - TLC1 - SummerSlam 2000
Angle (c) vs. HHHvs. Rock vs. Austin vs. Undertaker vs. Rikishi - Hell in a Cell - Armageddon 2000
2001
{Spoiler}Chris Jericho vs. Chris Benoit - Ladder Match - Royal Rumble 2001
Steve Austin vs. Triple H - 3 Stages of Hell - No Way Out 2001
Edge/Christian vs. Hardyz vs. Dudleyz - TLC2 - WrestleMania 17
The Rock (c) vs. Steve Austin - WrestleMania 17
Austin/HHH vs. Jericho/Benoit - Raw 5/21/01
Steve Austin (c) vs. Chris Benoit - Smackdown 5/31/01
Kurt Angle vs. Chris Benoit - Steel Cage - Raw 6/11/01
Kurt Angle vs. Shane McMahon - Street Fight - King of the Ring 2001
Steve Austin (c) vs. Kurt Angle - SummerSlam 2001
Team WWF vs. The Alliance - Elimination Match - Survivior Series 2001
2002
{Spoiler}The Rock vs. Hulk Hogan - WrestleMania 18
Kurt Angle vs. Edge - Hair vs Hair - Judgment Day 2002
The Undertaker (c) vs. The Rock vs. Kurt Angle - Vengeance 2002
Shawn Michaels vs. Triple H - SummerSlam 2002
Kurt Angle vs. Chris Benoit - Unforgiven 2002
Edge vs. Eddie Guerrero - No DQ - Smackdown 9/26/02
Angle/Benoit vs. Edge/Mysterio - No Mercy 2002
HHH vs. HBK vs. RVD vs. Jericho vs. Kane vs. Booker - Elimination Chamber - Survivor Series 02
2003
{Spoiler}Kurt Angle (c) vs. Chris Benoit - Royal Rumble 2003
Shawn Michaels vs. Chris Jericho - WrestleMania 19
Kurt Angle (c) vs. Brock Lesnar - WrestleMania 19
Kurt Angle vs. Brock Lesnar - SummerSlam 2003
Team Austin vs. Team Bischoff - Elimination Match - Survivor Series 2003
Brock Lesnar (c) vs. Chris Benoit - Smackdown 12/4/03
Triple H (c) vs. Shawn Michaels - Raw 12/29/03
2004
{Spoiler}Eddie Guerrero (c) vs. Kurt Angle - WrestleMania 20
Triple H (c) vs. Chris Benoit vs. Shawn Michaels - WrestleMania 20
Randy Orton vs. Cactus Jack - Street Fight - Backlash 2004
Chris Benoit (c) vs. Triple H vs. Shawn Michaels - Backlash 2004
Randy Orton (c) vs. Edge - Vengeance 2004
Chris Benoit (c) vs. Randy Orton - SummerSlam 2004
2005
{Spoiler}Edge vs. Benoit vs. Shelton vs. Kane vs. Jericho vs. Christian - MITB - WrestleMania 21
Shawn Michaels vs. Kurt Angle - WrestleMania 21
Shawn Michaels vs. Shelton Benjamin - Raw 5/2/05
John Cena (c) vs. JBL - I Quit Match - Judgment Day 2005
Shawn Michaels vs. Kurt Angle - Vengeance 2005
Batista (c) vs. Triple H - Hell in a Cell - Vengeance 2005
Matt Hardy vs. Edge - Steel Cage - Unforgiven 2005
2006
{Spoiler}Kurt Angle (c) vs. The Undertaker - No Way Out 2006
Mick Foley vs. Edge - Hardcore Match - WrestleMania 22
John Cena (c) vs. Triple H - WrestleMania 22
Edge (c) vs. John Cena - TLC - Unforgiven 2006
Londrick vs. MNM vs. Hardyz vs. Blue Bloods - Ladder Match - Armageddon 2006
2007
{Spoiler}John Cena (c) vs. Umaga - Last Man Standing - Royal Rumble 2007
Royal Rumble Match - Royal Rumble 2007
Batista (c) vs. The Undertaker - WrestleMania 23
John Cena (c) vs. Shawn Michaels - WrestleMania 23
John Cena vs. Shawn Michaels - Raw 4/23/07
John Cena (c) vs. Shawn Michaels vs. Edge vs. Randy Orton - Backlash 2007
Batista (c) vs. The Undertaker - Hell in a Cell - Survivor Series 2007
2008
{Spoiler}Royal Rumble Match - Royal Rumble 2008
Shawn Michaels vs. Ric Flair - WrestleMania 24
Edge (c) vs. The Undertaker - WrestleMania 24
The Undertaker vs. Edge - Hell in a Cell - SummerSlam 2008
Shawn Michaels vs. Chris Jericho - Unsanctioned Match - Unforgiven 2008
Triple H (c) vs. Jeff Hardy - No Mercy 2008
Chris Jericho (c) vs. Shawn Michaels - Ladder Match - No Mercy 2008
2009
{Spoiler}The Undertaker vs. Shawn Michaels - WrestleMania 25
John Cena (c) vs. Edge - Backlash 2009
Edge (c) vs. Jeff Hardy - Ladder Match - Extreme Rules 2009
Chris Jericho (c) vs. Rey Mysterio - The Bash 2009
Jeff Hardy (c) vs. CM Punk - TLC Match - SummerSlam 2009
CM Punk (c) vs. Jeff Hardy - Steel Cage Match - Smackdown 8/28/09
Randy Orton (c) vs. John Cena - I Quit Match - Breaking Point 2009
2010
{Spoiler}The Undertaker vs. Shawn Michaels - No DQ - WrestleMania 26
John Cena (c) vs. Batista - Last Man Standing - Extreme Rules 2010
Team WWE vs. The Nexus - Elimination Match - SummerSlam 2010
2011
{Spoiler}The Undertaker vs. Triple H - No Holds Barred - WrestleMania 27
Christian vs. Alberto Del Rio - Ladder Match - Extreme Rules 2011
Randy Orton (c) vs. Christian - Over the Limit 2011
Randy Orton (c) vs. Christian - Capitol Punishment 2011
John Cena (c) vs. CM Punk - Money in the Bank 2011
2012
{Spoiler}The Undertaker vs. Triple H - Hell in a Cell - WrestleMania 28
CM Punk (c) vs. Chris Jericho - WrestleMania 28
John Cena vs. The Rock - WrestleMania 28
Sheamus (c) vs. Daniel Bryan - Two out of Three Falls - Extreme Rules 2012
John Cena vs. Brock Lesnar - Extreme Rules 2012
CM Punk (c) vs. Daniel Bryan - Over the Limit 2012
CM Punk (c) vs. Daniel Bryan - No DQ - Money in the Bank 2012
The Shield vs. Daniel Bryan, Kane, and Ryback - TLC Match - TLC 2012
2013
{Spoiler}John Cena vs. CM Punk - Raw 2/25/13
The Undertaker vs. CM Punk - WrestleMania 29
Daniel Bryan vs. Seth Rollins - Raw 6/10/13
CM Punk vs. Chris Jericho - Payback 2013
CM Punk vs. Brock Lesnar - SummerSlam 2013
John Cena (c) vs. Daniel Bryan - SummerSlam 2013
Sami Zayn vs. Cesaro - 2/3 Falls - NXT 8/21/13
The Shield vs. The Rhodes Brothers - Battleground 2014
The Shield vs. The Rhodes Brothers - Raw 10/14/13
Randy Orton vs. Daniel Bryan - Raw 12/16/13
2014
{Spoiler}Daniel Bryan vs. Bray Wyatt - Royal Rumble 2014
John Cena vs. Cesaro - Raw 2/17/14
The Shield vs. The Wyatt Family - Elimination Chamber 2014
Sami Zayn vs. Cesaro - NXT Arrival
The Shield vs. The Wyatt Family - Raw 3/3/14
Daniel Bryan vs. Triple H - WrestleMania 30
Randy Orton (c) vs. Batista vs. Daniel Bryan - WrestleMania 30