Who’s turn was more shocking Ambrose or Rollins?

[ChitownKnight]

The first time around everyone thought dean was gonna turn, but we got swerved and Seth turned, but i figured there was gonna be a turn after the extreme rules ppv they had nothing left to do. When Ambrose turned yeah it was built up and everything but nobody would have expected them to do it that night

[Tenshigure]

I don't think the turn was the surprise, but the timing of it certainly was considering the WWE rarely are "on the ball" when it comes to such an action. The Dean turn this Monday was one of the rare moments where it made perfect sense and contributed to the overall feeling of the show that EVERYTHING on Raw is going to change with the power vacuum being left behind by Roman.

[Instant Classic]

Rollins because before the Shield broke up people thought he’d be stuck in the mid card.

[ayumidah]

The turn itself, Seth's. The actual coldness and brutality of it, Dean's.

[Albino Heat]

I think most were expecting Ambrose to break up the Shield, Roman to fight him and Seth to be the mid card face. Seth bring the traitor was a nice surprise.

[Captain Stud Muffin (BLM)]

Seth was more shocking. People expected when the Shield was breaking up it was going to be Ambrose and Rollins was going to be stuck in the midcard as a high flying babyface

The only shocking thing about Ambrose turn was the timing of it

[Deleted]

Seth's.

People expected Ambrose was going to be the one that turned and for the secondary option people expected it to be Ambrose and Rollins together. Nobody expected it to be Rollins betraying the both of them let alone at the time it happened. They had just gotten over a potential breakup issue, they had just turned face, they had beaten Evolution, they were at the top of their game and they hadn't really had any real major storylines as singles guys besides that Punk stuff so yeah, it was wild.

[sportatorium]

Seth- There wasn’t any real foreshadowing and it came after the won their feud with Evolution. The timing of Dean’s with Roman’s announcement was shocking, but they’ve been planting the seeds for weeks and not really trying to make it a surprise.

[Deleted]

As well done as it was, the only shocking thing about Dean's turn was the timing of it. I don't really remember people expecting Seth to be the one to turn when The Shield first broke up, so I'd have to say him.

[Dub H]

Oct 24, 2018 11:36:39 GMT -5 ayumidah said:

The turn itself, Seth's. The actual coldness and brutality of it, Dean's.

Seth turn came out of nowhere ,Dean was already telegraphed and set up.

But I dont think anyoen expected the Brutality that was Dean's turn.

[Crappler El 0 M]

Seth's came out of nowhere. They did not plant seeds that Seth might turn on them.
Dean's came after weeks of "Will he or won't he" angles.

[Super Duper Dragunov]

Seth's wasn't expected.

Dean's was.

[chronocross]

As mentioned Seth's turn came out of nowhere, Evolution had lost two straight matches to the Shield and Batista walked out, there was nothing hinting that Seth would turn at all, unlike Dean's turn which had been hinted at for over a month now.

[Chainsaw]

Dean's definitely benefits from the timing with Roman's announcement. But it sounds like they've been treating it for a few weeks, and a lot of people were saying even before he returned, Dean would be turning heel. Seth wasn't even the one people were expecting to turn in the aftermath of their match with Evolution, everyone was expecting it to be either Dean or Roman, so having it be Seth, especially when they were at the height of their face turn, shook everyone up.