Is Gargano The King of PPVs In WWE?

[Captain Stud Muffin (BLM)]

I swear it seems like after every takeover I have to ask a question or make a case in regards to Gargano but he continues to deliver at each Takeover and I can't even remember the last bad Takeover match he was in

You can pencil him in every Takeover to wrestle a "4 star match" or better and hopefully it one day translates to the main roster

[ASYLUMHAUSEN]

Yes.

[kidkamikaze10]

Yeah

[Porky's Butthole]

At the very least, he is "Mr. Takeover".

[BlackoutCreature]

...

He hasn't wrestled on any PPV's yet.

[Abdullah]

Question: Hunter brought up the thought that some people weren’t going to be leaving NXT.

Should that include Gargano at this point or would you take your chances with him on the main roster?

[Deleted]

They don’t call him Johnny Takeover for nothing.

[realist]

Jan 27, 2019 10:55:19 GMT -5 Abdullah said:

Question: Hunter brought up the thought that some people weren’t going to be leaving NXT.

Should that include Gargano at this point or would you take your chances with him on the main roster?

He can either be tearing it up on NXT Takeover shows over and over, or he can be a comedy jobber on ppv preshow matches. As long as he is paid well, I hope he stays on NXT forever.

[Captain Stud Muffin (BLM)]

Jan 27, 2019 10:55:19 GMT -5 Abdullah said:

Question: Hunter brought up the thought that some people weren’t going to be leaving NXT.

Should that include Gargano at this point or would you take your chances with him on the main roster?

If HHH ever truly wants NXT to be its own brand he will need Gargano who has replaced Sami Zayn as the guy I associate NXT with

Sami was the guy who had banger matches and was always involved in something good and I think Gargano has surpassed him in that regard

Unlike Sami tho, he gave in to his dark side to win

[Bang Bang Bart]

Jan 26, 2019 22:31:30 GMT -5 Porky's Butthole said:

At the very least, he is "Johnny Takeover".

Fixed.

[CMPunkyBrewster]

As much as I love Omega, Okada, AJ, Seth, Brian and all the rest...

Johnny Gargano may be the best in the world. Tommaso Ciampa is equally deserving of being in the conversation.

[Bo Rida]

Sasha and Sami were great in singles matches. The Revival in tag matches. Gargano's been stealing the show in tag and then singles matches for a few years now so yeah.

Of course looking at the other names I mentioned since they joined the main roster proves he has an advantage on Nxt as it provides the environment that allows him to put on classics. May not happen on the main roster. You can just make things mean more with fewer ppvs.

Seth, AJ, Bryan etc are all pretty consistent but get lumbered with go nowhere fueds, bad booking, crap finishes and general filler.

[Moppy]

Jan 27, 2019 16:09:40 GMT -5 CMPunkyBrewster said:

As much as I love Omega, Okada, AJ, Seth, Brian and all the rest...

Johnny Gargano may be the best in the world. Tommaso Ciampa is equally deserving of being in the conversation.

Damn straight - I love to see workrate and athleticism as much as the next fan, and Gargano has that in spades, but is there any wrestler in the world right now who can make you straight up care about the events within and the outcomes of his matches more than Johnny Wrestling? Not as far as I can see.