Would You Rather Have Had Sasha Banks or Asuka Career?

[Captain Stud Muffin (BLM)]

Let's discuss it. 

There been some Asuka threads lately (including one of my own) and the recent thread asked a question has she been the most accoladed woman to not be "pushed". Well, let's bring in Sasha Banks who I think also may fit that criteria.

Sasha Banks up until this year has had multiple women championship reigns but has actually presented as a choker in that regard. Believe it or not, she is the record holder for Raw women title reigns but only Bayley and Nia Jax held the title less days then her. She has got the "historic matchups" like Hell in A Cell but yet she has not won a WM match. The 4HW is so stacked that right now you can argue she is the "least accomplished" member of that group after Bayley just went on a crazy reign. She is now being given her time to at least carve out a nice title reign for her resume

On the other side we got Asuka. We already talked on her enough that doesn't need to be expanded on. Like Sasha she also does not have a win at Mania if I remember correctly. Credible champion but not someone given the focus in terms of big feuds. The only woman who has been put on par with the 4HW. 

This is not just main roster either, NXT is included 

[Ishmeal Loves Kaseyhausen]

Which had made more money? I pick that one.

[Captain Stud Muffin (BLM)]

Dec 21, 2020 9:34:26 GMT -5 Ishmeal Loves Kaseyhausen said:

Which had made more money? I pick that one.

I would think they about the same 

In terms of merch, Asuka has her mask and shirts will Sasha has the rings and glasses  

[msc]

Sasha had more groundbreaking moments but Asuka got booked better (eventually).

I guess Asuka overall but I'd rather have boths careers than Molly Holly's scraps about 15 years ago.

[fw91]

I mean neither match the in ring prowess of Melina or Alicia Fox

[thehottag]

Sasha was in the Mandolorian, so her

[Deleted]

Sasha.

She's going to make more money long term because she can get paid not just for any of her solo stuff, but any of the Four Horsewomen stuff and the marketing of that crew is going to be super huge in ten years when little girls inspired by them start showing up at the PC.

Plus, I think Sasha is the only one out of the two of them with a truly CLASSIC match in the Bayley match. Asuka's great, but her matches are just great. They don't have the huge status that match already has.

[Captain Stud Muffin (BLM)]

Dec 21, 2020 10:19:05 GMT -5 @phoenixtrigger said:

Sasha.

She's going to make more money long term because she can get paid not just for any of her solo stuff, but any of the Four Horsewomen stuff and the marketing of that crew is going to be super huge in ten years when little girls inspired by them start showing up at the PC.

Plus, I think Sasha is the only one out of the two of them with a truly CLASSIC match in the Bayley match. Asuka's great, but her matches are just great. They don't have the huge status that match already has.

Asuka/Charlotte is a classic at Mania 

Also I said had, so meaning up until this point not future. Obviously you rather have the not even 30 years old Sasha for the long term 

[James Fabiano]

Did Asuka tornado DDT BOBA FRIGGIN' FETT? WELL DID SHE??

[Deleted]

Dec 21, 2020 10:26:17 GMT -5 Captain Stud Muffin (BLM) said:

Dec 21, 2020 10:19:05 GMT -5 @phoenixtrigger said:

Sasha.

She's going to make more money long term because she can get paid not just for any of her solo stuff, but any of the Four Horsewomen stuff and the marketing of that crew is going to be super huge in ten years when little girls inspired by them start showing up at the PC.

Plus, I think Sasha is the only one out of the two of them with a truly CLASSIC match in the Bayley match. Asuka's great, but her matches are just great. They don't have the huge status that match already has.

Asuka/Charlotte is a classic at Mania 

Also I said had, so meaning up until this point not future. Obviously you rather have the not even 30 years old Sasha for the long term 

It's a perfectly fine match, but I don't think anyone talks about it with the same reverence and promotion people talk about Takeover: Brooklyn with. 

[Push R Truth]

Dec 21, 2020 10:09:05 GMT -5 thehottag said:

Sasha was in the Mandolorian, so her

Shit, if I was Sasha "DDT'ing Boba Fett" would be higher on the resume than "WWE Women's Champion"

[Captain Stud Muffin (BLM)]

Dec 21, 2020 10:50:21 GMT -5 @phoenixtrigger said:

Dec 21, 2020 10:26:17 GMT -5 Captain Stud Muffin (BLM) said:

Asuka/Charlotte is a classic at Mania 

Also I said had, so meaning up until this point not future. Obviously you rather have the not even 30 years old Sasha for the long term 

It's a perfectly fine match, but I don't think anyone talks about it with the same reverence and promotion people talk about Takeover: Brooklyn with. 

More so cause of the result not cause of the match 

Same will happen to Rhea/Charlotte who I think their match was better then Asuka/Charlotte and Bayley/Sasha

[ayumidah]

Asuka. She has all her side stuff, multiple time womens and tag champ, and was part of AWE-SKA on Mixed Match Challenge. Seems more fun than a lot of what Sasha had to slough through at times.

[Deleted]

The one who's undefeated at TLC, Asuka!

["Evil Brood" Jackson Vanik]

I feel like Sasha has been hurt a ton in her career (especially to the head) so Asuka.

[Deleted]

I will take Asuka and her Youtube career.

[The Kevstaaa]

Sasha Banks, though you really can't go wrong with either woman.