Who is the third best member of the shield?

[ChitownKnight]

Now Theory thinks it’s Seth, CM Punk thinks it’s Mox. Who do you think is the third best success wise or talent wise?

[Oh Cry Me a Screwball]

Kurt Angle

[ThankGodForSidJustice]

Success
1. Reigns
2. Rollins
3. Ambrose

Talent
1. Rollins
2. Ambrose
3. Reigns

[Allie Kitsune]

Kassius Ohno.

[A Little Doo Doo]

If I'm just basing it off my own personal preference, Roman. Nothing against him, he's the biggest star of the three, I've just always liked Seth and Dean more.

[ThankGodForSidJustice]

Dec 23, 2022 23:11:16 GMT -5 A Little Doo Doo said:

If I'm just basing it off my own personal preference, Roman. Nothing against him, he's the biggest star of the three, I've just always liked Seth and Dean more.

Same. Roman was the one with the most star potential and highest ceiling as far being someone being a draw and money player so I don't blame WWE at all for making him the chosen one. Obviously he's been incredibly successful and he definitely carries himself like a star. As far as talent goes especially in ring though I think he's below the other two. I find his in ring style super repetitive and not interesting.

Ambrose/Moxley has always been my favorite even though kayfabe wise he's behind the other two as far as accomplishments and booking goes. Rollins is the most talented in the ring but is third when it comes charisma in that he doesn't have the larger then life appeal Reigns nor the blue collar everyman appeal Moxley has.

[The Legendary Ring Troll {BLM}]

1) Reigns
2) Mox
3) Rollins

Reigns is WWE’s top dawg, without a doubt.

Moxley is AEW’s ace, he’s the go to guy when they need someone to throw the company on his back.

Rollins is the most talented wrestler of the group, and highly successful in his own right, but he’s not really been “THE” guy even when champion, and the closest he’s come is when him and Reigns went head to head and looked like two supervillains interacting. If Ambrose has never left, Rollins would likely move up a spot.

[tafkaga]

It's Rollins for me. Best in-ring performer but of the three he has the least "it" factor.

[Instant Classic]

It’s Rollins. Sure WWE wise it’s certainly Ambrose/Mox but wrestling as a whole Mox is more accomplished than Rollins. Reigns is the best from accomplishments.

[Finish Uncle Muffin’s Story]

If they all stayed in WWE, it was clear the depth chart was Reigns, Rollins, Mox/Ambrose. But Mox went out and had one of the best runs in modern wrestling, so that puts him at #2 for me now.

I admit that begrudgingly, Roman is above them both right now. This run is what put him over the top for me.

[coleslaw]

Before the Tribal Chief run I definitely would have said Roman.

Now I'd say Seth. Probably the best in-ring talent out of the three but as a total package Mox and Roman have him beat

[J is Justice]

Best talker: Mox.

Best in-ring: Seth.

Best all-rounder: Roman.