Rate the Collision!: 9/16/2023

[Xxcjb01xX [PIECE OF: SH-]]

SATURDAY NIGHT'S ALL RIGHT FOR FIGHTING... AND VOTING! Another new weekly Poll for AEW Fans as I hopefully can do this most every week, if not, we'll see if I can get some people to fill in some times, Saturday's a more busy day for me, usually, but either way, it's time to see how AEW's second Prime Time two hour show does... it's time to RATE THE COLLISION!


Last Weeks Most Voted Rating: 8

------ 2023


6/17: 7.91 (20% DW)

6/24: 7.92 (16% DW)

7/1: 7.36 (40% DW)

7/8: 8.43 (23% DW)

7/15: 8.55 (17% DW)

7/22: 6.69 (27% DW)

7/29: 8.59 (10% DW)

8/5: 7.72 (24% DW)

8/12: 8.00 (35% DW)

8/19: 6.16 (26% DW)

8/26: 7.20 (47% DW)


------ CM PUNK IS FIRED FROM AEW



9/2: 8.33 (9% DW)

9/9: 7.51 (14% DW)
9/16: TBD

[Finish Uncle Muffin’s Story]

I’ll give it a 22 out of 10.

[Cyno]

Going with an 8. Solid show up and down the card. Even Scorpio vs Andrade was pretty good.

Would've been a 9, but Kevin Kelly still sucks and he somehow screwed up saying the word "no."

[Doo Doo Dickhead]

Really strong 7. I think Collision is enjoyable every week, but it's been finding a nice groove the last couple weeks.

[J is Justice]

Missed most of it but I enjoyed the main event.

[DSR]

I give it an 8. Very entertaining show, but Kevin Kelly sucks.

[Dub H]

6/10

You cant pay me to watch Andrade/Sky without sleeping.

Nor a britt match. And the match before the main event was also not very interesting.

DO won tho!On Tv!

[bob]

Sept 16, 2023 21:26:27 GMT -5 DSR said:

I give it an 8. Very entertaining show, but Kevin Kelly sucks.

Same

[Doo Doo Dickhead]

Sept 16, 2023 22:27:58 GMT -5 bob said:

Sept 16, 2023 21:26:27 GMT -5 DSR said:

I give it an 8. Very entertaining show, but Kevin Kelly sucks.

Same

You don't suck, bob.

SPOILER: Click to show

{Spoiler}I know what you meant.

["Evil Brood" Jackson Vanik]

9 - that was a lot of fun!

[Denny Zen is Cooking™]

Good solid 8. Honestly the only real negative was the f***ing lame ass being like NOTICE ME JIMPAI with his stupid sign in the front row all night.

[Facetious]

While I prefer the chaotic nature of Dynamite, Collision has really found it's groove and could become my favorite. They just REALLY REALLY need to ditch kevin Kelly. He's absolute trash. 8

[King (Super) Dragunov]

I tried. I just can't deal with Kevin Kelly.

I think it was just a perfect storm of migraine coming on + not in the mood to hear stupid bullshit = irritating things are even more irritating.

If I feel better I'll try again tomorrow when I have some free time, and watch it on mute.

I like what I've seen of the show, but Kelly depletes any enjoyment by being awful.

So for now "barely watched".

[daaave]

Good first hour. Tough watch 2nd hour.

Andrade vs Scorpio Sky quite possibly the most boring match pairing in AEW history. Andrade just does nothing for me. Not sure why as he's great in the ring. I think he's much better as a heel

[KME]

Like an 8 I think. Was feeling like a 7 for most of the show and felt very minor at times (which is understandable because next week is absolutely stacked across all three shows) but was elevated by the main event for me. Really enjoyed the opener, love a lot of the matches they set up, particularly FTR vs Aussie Open, but can't wait for White/Andrade and Starks/Danielson II as well, thought Bowens vs Silver was very enjoyable, loved the Toni segment and, as I alluded to, really enjoyed the main event, completely bought Britt winning twice and that's what you want from a big title match, to genuinely feel like it could go either way.

Much better than it looked on paper.

[Deleted]

5...Kelly is so bad and it's unfortunate as I had heard positive things about his work with NJPW. Maybe it just translated differently to viewers?

Was a definite filler show that left the crowd boo'ing every finish besides FTRs. Looks like it will take awhile for it to find it's footing which is to be expected in the wake of everything. It felt like a prior extended rampage episode. I also feel like they can't make up their mind if BCC is heel or not and they seem to switch at random as well...

With that said there were some fun things with Eddie, Storm and RJ and the savages of sauce but with the seeming "trying to do too much" in a bunch of the matches that left awkward spots and botches as well as the glaring production issue this certainly wasn't their best show.

[Glitch]

Dark Order scores a win, Orange and Hook, killer promo by Kingston. Post-punk Collision is fire.

[Mr Mario Mario]

Yeah I’m gonna give it a 5 as well

Good opener and good ender but in between?

Iron Savages vs FTR was meh and then following up with the workhorsemen?

Bowens vs Silver was alright

Then we got a Scorpio Sky match followed by the Hardys vs Righteous……..Took 1 point off just for scheduling them back to back alone

[clifford]

7/10. I feel like Collison needs a little more star power. You compare it to Dynamite cards at the moment and it's lacking a little, feel less important in comparison. Everything on this episode ranged from ok to good, nothing great.