Favorite Metallica album?

[noleafclover1980]

Ok, get to voting. My personal favorite is RtL

[Bishblast]

1. And Justice For All
2. Master Of Puppets
3. Ride The Lightning
4. Metallica
5. Kill Em All

IMO...

[Bake Or Die]

1.Reload
2....And Justice For All

[Clash, Never a Meter Maid]

I only own two Metallica albums- Load and Master of Puppets. My favorite between them is Load, though.

Don't look at me that way.

[Deleted]

Master of Puppets

[Phosphor Glow]

Honestly? Death Magnetic.

Yeah, I liked it THAT much. It's awesome and perfectly paced and just...incredible.

I'd rank them like this:

1) Death Magnetic
2) Master of Puppets
3) Black Album
4) Ride the Lightning
5) ...And Justice For All
6) Load
7) Reload
8) St. Anger
9) Kill 'Em All

Probably a weird list, and I don't include Garage, Inc. or S&M usually.

[Deleted]

Ride the Lightning.

Who the f*** voted St Anger?

[Bishblast]

I guess load has aged quite well... while not critically panned, it was a notorious disappointment to fans. Personally I've always felt ReLoad was a superior album, I despised St Anger from day of release to this day, and Death Magnetic was a noble effort but felt obviously pushed.

FTR, I saw them in concert at the 2008 Bonnaroo in TN, they played all classics... no Load, St Anger, or Death Magnetic, only one song from ReLoad (The Memory Remains). The rest was all Kill Em All - Metallics, plus some Garage Days. Excellent show... best metal concert I've ever been to, and one of the best headlining sets I've seen at Bonnaroo.

Edit : If not for the tin can sound engineering, AJFA would be a damn near perfect album.

[chac]

Puppets

[Soultastic]

1) Master of Pupets

2) Ride the Lightning

3) Death Magnetic

4) Kill 'Em All

5) ...And Justice For All

6) Black Album

7) Reload

8) Garage Inc.

9) S&M

10,11,12..."n") future Metallica albums

"n"+1) Load

"n"+2,"n"+3,"n"+4..."n"+"m") future Metallica compilation and concert albums

"n"+"m"+1) St. Anger

[Bub (BLM)]

Sept 11, 2010 15:30:17 GMT -5 Soultastic said:

1) Master of Pupets

2) Ride the Lightning

3) Death Magnetic

4) Kill 'Em All

5) ...And Justice For All

6) Black Album

7) Reload

8) Garage Inc.

9) S&M

10,11,12..."n") future Metallica albums

"n"+1) Load

"n"+2,"n"+3,"n"+4..."n"+"m") future Metallica compilation and concert albums

"n"+"m"+1) St. Anger

I fully endorse this post.

[who throws a shoe?!]

Sept 11, 2010 15:24:09 GMT -5 @aaronmaiden said:

Ride the Lightning.

Who the f*** voted St Anger?

I hardly ever use this, but lol ;D

Master of Puppets.

[Chronos]

Hilarity is listening to acoustic chamber pop while you vote on a Metallica album.

Anyhow, I voted ...Justice, here's the full roundup:

1. ...And Justice for All
2. Master of Puppets
2. Ride the Lightning (yes, a tie)
4. Reload
5. Kill 'em All
6. Black Album
7. Load
8. St. Anger

I haven't heard Death Magnetic yet actually, I really need to get on that. And despite the place of the album it's on, Creeping Death is by far my favorite Metallica song.

[Paul]

The Black Album- I prefer it to any of their previous albums.

[A Dubya (El Hombre Muerto)]

My favorite is The Black Album. I like "...And Justice For All" & "Master of Puppets" too, but the album I loved almost every song on was the Black Album. "The Unforgiven" is one of my favorite songs

[W?Y]

Crap, I voted ...And Justice, but I really meant S&M. Also, it warms my heart to see people actually liking Load & ReLoad. Bless you, my good men.

[britishbulldog]

Death Magnet is a good album as far as writing. However, the Mastering and engineering on that album is absolutely terrible.

[celticjobber]

My top 5:

1) Black Album
2) Load
3) Garage Inc.
4) And Justice For All
5) Re-Load

[Bob Schlapowitz]

I've always had a soft spot for "...And Justice For All".

[dabossftw]

Kill 'Em All is my favorite. It changes from time to time, though. So many awesome albums, so many great songs.