Avatar: The Last Airbender Mafia (Game Over)

[Orange]

Apr 25, 2013 21:59:10 GMT -5 BoilerRoomBrawler said:

I say if you're not busy answering questions them get busy asking them. I think productivity is the point, not checklists.

Orange, as a Townie, would you rather vote before or after the tipping point?

Not sure, actually. If the ball is rolling and I feel confident, than I might as well cast my vote. However, I always try to do my best to find suspects before a lynch train forms, so I'm 50/50. It all depends on the circumstances as lynches differ from case to case.

[Brandon Walsh is Insane.]

Apr 26, 2013 12:12:22 GMT -5 Mochi Lone Wolf said:

Notorious has been busy from what I've seen from his mod posts in TMNT. I think it's unfair to call him out at this point.

Single H also only has one post, and Wolf with 3.

The difference between the three is that Wolf's post seemed to be pushing forward discussion while the other two didn't.

[Mochi Lone Wolf]

Well, I can't speak for Single H. All I know is that Notorious has a reason for being inactive thus far. They both still have 4 days to get active.

[Mochi Lone Wolf]

Oh wow. Didn't realize that we had to ask the question to the person above us on the list. I just thought we had to ask random people in the game. Wasn't paying attention.


So, Wolf Hurricane, is Notorious your top suspect right now or are you still waiting for him to get more active before making any judgments?

[Big Bad Brad]

I thought we had to ask questions of the person below us and since no one is above me I was the first to join that means the last person who joined would ask me a question and that would be you AH.

[Big Bad Brad]

Apr 26, 2013 12:43:37 GMT -5 Mochi Lone Wolf said:

Oh wow. Didn't realize that we had to ask the question to the person above us on the list. I just thought we had to ask random people in the game. Wasn't paying attention.


So, Wolf Hurricane, is Notorious your top suspect right now or are you still waiting for him to get more active before making any judgments?

I was right it is the person below us here is the post where it all started

Apr 23, 2013 16:57:46 GMT -5 No Longer a Produceman said:

What'd I do to get lumped in worth them? Oh wait....yeah lol.

Here's an idea: everyone ask the person below you on the sign up list a Mafia related question. This will help get discussion going (and maybe get scum to slip up).


@wolfanghurricane: On day one, lynches are important. Would you be willing to help lynch someone on Day One even if you weren't convinced that they were scum? Why/why not?

1. Brad is the FAN Idol Judge!
2. Waffel113: The Last Airbender
3. Lodi "Riddler" Rulz
4. BoilerRoomBrawler
5. Evil Single H
6. Zack Morris is Insane.
7. Notorious
8. Classy Lady
9. Orange
10. Produceman
11. Wolf Hurricane
12. Artificial Human

I would ask Waffel, Waffel asks Lodi, Lodi asks Boilerroom, Boilerroom ask Evil H, Evil H ask Zack, Zack asks Notorious, Notorious asks Classy, Classy asks Orange, Orange asks Produce, Produce asks Wolf, Wolf asks AH and AH asks me.

[BoilerRoomBrawler]

I don't know about the busy card. I run FAWA every week and I'd argue it's more work than modding a Mafia game any day of the week. No disrespect. By the same notion, over in TMNT, Sloth Spartan is one of the co-GMs of WWE: FAN Edition, as is sMurfy, whose inactivity lends your observation a point. And there's Brad's daily Name a Flaw threads too.

Overall, participating in a Mafia game shouldn't be difficult to commit to.

[Mochi Lone Wolf]

Oh alright. I'm having bad vertigo today that's why my posts are really clunky right now. If that's the case then:




Brad, how long would you plan on waiting for someone to ask/answer a question before getting suspicious?

[Big Bad Brad]

Apr 26, 2013 12:52:55 GMT -5 BoilerRoomBrawler said:

I don't know about the busy card. I run FAWA every week and I'd argue it's more work than modding a Mafia game any day of the week. No disrespect. By the same notion, over in TMNT, Sloth Spartan is one of the co-GMs of WWE: FAN Edition, as is sMurfy, whose inactivity lends your observation a point. And there's Brad's daily Name a Flaw threads too.

Overall, participating in a Mafia game shouldn't be difficult to commit to.

Of all the things I do on the forum you would pick the simplest, that Name a Flaw takes 2 or 3 minutes each day to post.

It would of been better to mention CCW or being a Fan Idol Judge or Running a Greatest Video Game Franchise Tournament or being in another Mafia game at the same time those things take a lot of time but I still manage to participate in this game the best I can.

[Big Bad Brad]

Apr 26, 2013 12:54:28 GMT -5 Mochi Lone Wolf said:

Oh alright. I'm having bad vertigo today that's why my posts are really clunky right now. If that's the case then:




Brad, how long would you plan on waiting for someone to ask/answer a question before getting suspicious?

I say about a day before the deadline, when is the deadline in this game, just looked at the first page its April 30th so 4 days.

I say by the 29th if anybody doesn't ask/answer a question by then has to be suspicious I mean everybody should have plenty of time to answer or ask a question by that time.

[BoilerRoomBrawler]

Looks like I lucked out on asking Single H a question. I didn't realize that either, AH. And after all that "pay attention" stuff in TMNT Mafia too.

I think Produceman's aim was to either ensure everyone asked a question and answered one for the sake of discussion or else to ensure that Mafia had to ask a question and answer one. Create a trail of sorts. Maybe both.

That said, I think Produceman was at least ensuring discussion from everyone. I don't think he meant that suggestion to be carried out only as stated. Just a minimum. Care to clarify, Produce?

[BoilerRoomBrawler]

Apr 26, 2013 12:57:18 GMT -5 Big Bad Brad said:

Apr 26, 2013 12:52:55 GMT -5 BoilerRoomBrawler said:

I don't know about the busy card. I run FAWA every week and I'd argue it's more work than modding a Mafia game any day of the week. No disrespect. By the same notion, over in TMNT, Sloth Spartan is one of the co-GMs of WWE: FAN Edition, as is sMurfy, whose inactivity lends your observation a point. And there's Brad's daily Name a Flaw threads too.

Overall, participating in a Mafia game shouldn't be difficult to commit to.

Of all the things I do on the forum you would pick the simplest, that Name a Flaw takes 2 or 3 minutes each day to post.

It would of been better to mention CCW or being a Fan Idol Judge or Running a Greatest Video Game Franchise Tournament or being in another Mafia game at the same time those things take a lot of time but I still manage to participate in this game the best I can.

Oh oops. I somehow had it in my head that Daime/BitW did CCW. *shrug* Regardless, you not only confirmed my counterpoint, but you reinforced it.

That said, you do FAN Idol, eh? It's too bad we're past the joke vote stage.

[Brandon Walsh is Insane.]

I thought it was above; my apologies. I couldn't remember to ask the above or below... I'm pretty sure I asked Notorious a question, though.

[Big Bad Brad]

Of course I do Fan Idol didn't my Username give it way

Brad is the Fan Idol Judge

I was a contestant but got eliminated and got promoted to being a Judge which I very much enjoy!

Enough of that if anybody has any more questions for me I'll gladly answer and if I think of any more questions I'll ask what I can for now I need to finish this round in CCW so I might not post as much for the rest of the day I'll try if I can.

[BoilerRoomBrawler]

Apr 26, 2013 13:09:19 GMT -5 Big Bad Brad said:

Of course I do Fan Idol didn't my Username give it way

Brad is the Fan Idol Judge.

*facepalm* I'm on a roll today. Though to be honest I just skim over everything but "Brad."

But yes, enough with that.

Trying to think of more questions.

Has anyone asked Waffell a question yet?

[Mochi Lone Wolf]

I've decided to let my question for Wolf stand though. No one has asked me a question yet I don't think.

[Brandon Walsh is Insane.]

Apr 26, 2013 13:09:19 GMT -5 Big Bad Brad said:

Of course I do Fan Idol didn't my Username give it way

Brad is the Fan Idol Judge

I was a contestant but got eliminated and got promoted to being a Judge which I very much enjoy!

Enough of that if anybody has any more questions for me I'll gladly answer and if I think of any more questions I'll ask what I can for now I need to finish this round in CCW so I might not post as much for the rest of the day I'll try if I can.

Are you ok with bandwagon voting this game?

[Big Bad Brad]

Not sure I do think we need a lynch and there is a chance the lynch could be mafia it has happened in the past.

I think if we are close to a lynch toward the end of the day phase I don't see a problem in putting a vote in to make sure we get a lynch because if we don't lynch we will just be as clueless in the upcoming day phase.

[No Longer a Produceman]

My main goal was to stimulate discussion involving everyone and i managed to do that. That gives us a trail to look at in later days and valuable information right now. my system was just an idea to get discussion flowing. you can ask more questions to anyone you like. the more the better

[Classy Lady]

Man, honestly, I feel like an inactive poster sometimes. I post a couple times a day and it seems every time I check back there's an entire new page. But I try only posting when I have something valid to say.

And if it comes down to it, inactivity lynch over a no lynch. Effort over no effort.

I'm going to throw in on the bandwagon discussion in that I'm okay with it, seeing as it's usually not actually a true mindless bandwagon, more like "oh, hey, he's got a point."