Would you want a WWE-produced Scott Hall DVD?

[Voldemar H. "Brak" Guerta]

I was thinking about how awesome Hall used be be, and how he's had a handful of great matches over the past couple of decades. I'd also like to see a biography of his life too, touching on how he got into the business, his "Razor Ramon" days, his jump to WCW, his alcoholism, and his life after wrestling. I think it would be a great DVD, but it would have to include Hall in it to provide his own insight & stories (i.e. the Bret Hart DVD, the Jake the Snake DVD, Road Warriors DVD, etc.).

[Stotty]

It would be impossible to make on without talking about his "personal demons", which would just be sad, so no

[Voldemar H. "Brak" Guerta]

rob1 said:

It would be impossible to make on without talking about his "personal demons", which would just be sad, so no

I disagree, the Jake the Snake DVD had an excellent documentary that touched on Jake's personal problems, and Jake has had way more personal problems than Hall, so I don't think a Hall DVD would be that bad.

[Error]

No, I just can't think of a time I liked him without Nash involved. I'd rather have one with those two talking about their early days in WCW, to WWF, back to WCW, the nWo, the Outsiders and the return to WWE (if WWE has the rights to TNA by then, then that as well). Add in some Waltman, Trips and HBK stories to go with it and it would be gold for me.

[Godhand]

eh why not. Hall had a pretty sweet career and I'd buy the dvd. Of course theres about 50 people I'd rather see dvds made for.

[Voldemar H. "Brak" Guerta]

jinxed said:

No, I just can't think of a time I liked him without Nash involved. I'd rather have one with those two talking about their early days in WCW, to WWF, back to WCW, the nWo, the Outsiders and the return to WWE (if WWE has the rights to TNA by then, then that as well). Add in some Waltman, Trips and HBK stories to go with it and it would be gold for me.

Eh, that's basically a "Kliq" DVD, I'm just talking about Hall.

[tna]

I've always found Scott Hall boring compared to the rest of the cliq or nWo.

I don't think he's contributed anything significant to the history of wrestling.

And he's a boring wrestler.

[sandimashigh]

I wouldn't mind a DVD with just his matches on there. Although I can see a documentry going the sappy route of "overcoming his demons/adversity, blah blah." Just Give me my WMX Ladder Match dammit!

[Error]

theloosecannon said:

jinxed said:

No, I just can't think of a time I liked him without Nash involved. I'd rather have one with those two talking about their early days in WCW, to WWF, back to WCW, the nWo, the Outsiders and the return to WWE (if WWE has the rights to TNA by then, then that as well). Add in some Waltman, Trips and HBK stories to go with it and it would be gold for me.

Eh, that's basically a "Kliq" DVD, I'm just talking about Hall.

That's where the first sentence comes in:

No, I just can't think of a time I liked him without Nash involved.

I threw in HBK and the rest to round it out.

[robferatu]

If the did it I could only see it as two-pack type deal.
With Hall and Nash.
Cause I don't feel you could do a whole DVD focused on one of them, but you could do a three disc set focused on both.

[Garee]

optimistseatbabies said:

If the did it I could only see it as two-pack type deal.
With Hall and Nash.
Cause I don't feel you could do a whole DVD focused on one of them, but you could do a three disc set focused on both.

I could go for this, it would be cool

[tna]

optimistseatbabies said:

If the did it I could only see it as two-pack type deal.
With Hall and Nash.
Cause I don't feel you could do a whole DVD focused on one of them, but you could do a three disc set focused on both.

Nash could have his own DVD. He's had a noteworthy, eventfull career.

[Rorschach]

tna said:

I've always found Scott Hall boring compared to the rest of the cliq or nWo.

I don't think he's contributed anything significant to the history of wrestling.

And he's a boring wrestler.

And that's your opinion, and you're entitled to it. I just so happen to remember, however, a certain history making ladder match at Wrestlemania X.

And he WAS the first member of the nWo. Him crossing over to wCw like he did was pretty historic in and of itself.

[tna]

karnage70 said:

tna said:

I've always found Scott Hall boring compared to the rest of the cliq or nWo.

I don't think he's contributed anything significant to the history of wrestling.

And he's a boring wrestler.

And that's your opinion, and you're entitled to it. I just so happen to remember, however, a certain history making ladder match at Wrestlemania X.

And he WAS the first member of the nWo. Him crossing over to wCw like he did was pretty historic in and of itself.

If he didn't face Shawn Michaels in a ladder match at WM X then someone else would of. And I've seen enough of both wrestlers to have a pretty good idea which one was creative enough to come up with all those (then) original spots.

If he didn't appear on Nitro someone else would've. He was just a mid-carder at the time he left WWE so it was kind of like "so what". Nash, on the other hand, had just come off the heels of a feud with Undertaker and Shawn Michaels.

["IcePic" Rick Cobos]

maybe a single disc, that's it

[Voldemar H. "Brak" Guerta]

I can understand not liking Hall, but not giving the guy any credit is just ignorant.

[tna]

I felt so awful for Austin at WM18 that he had to feud with Scott Hall.

It would be like if HHH and Undertaker retired and both came back in a few years, with HHH feuding with Cena and Undertaker getting stuck with Carlito.

They just aren't on the same level of talent or significance.

[Rorschach]

tna said:

karnage70 said:

And that's your opinion, and you're entitled to it. I just so happen to remember, however, a certain history making ladder match at Wrestlemania X.

And he WAS the first member of the nWo. Him crossing over to wCw like he did was pretty historic in and of itself.

If he didn't face Shawn Michaels in a ladder match at WM X then someone else would of. And I've seen enough of both wrestlers to have a pretty good idea which one was creative enough to come up with all those (then) original spots.

If he didn't appear on Nitro someone else would've. He was just a mid-carder at the time he left WWE so it was kind of like "so what". Nash, on the other hand, had just come off the heels of a feud with Undertaker and Shawn Michaels.

This is a funny argument, as it makes little sense, but LOGICALLY could be true.

For example, if Neal Armstrong or Buzz Aldrin hadn't walked on the moon, someone else would have. BUT IT WAS THEM.

If the Wright Brothers didn't fly at Kittyhawk, someone else would have......BUT IT WAS THEM.

If Jack Ruby didn't shoot Oswald, someone else would have. BUT IT WAS HIM.


If Abraham Lincoln didn't give the Gettysburg Address, someone else would have......you get the point. Thus, while denying someone thier place in history based on the fact that 'it would have been someone else anyway" is technically true, since it COULD have been someone else......it is ultimately irrelevant, since it WAS that person, and not someone else.


It WAS Hall against Michaels. It WAS Hall on NITRO. Give the guy SOME credit. If he was as unimportant as YOU say, I HIGHLY doubt that Vince McMahon and company would have gone to the trouble to create a "Fake Razor" to go along with the "Fake Diesel".....after all, why waste time on a cipher?

[robferatu]

I've always believed if Hall would have stayed with the WWF he would have eventually had World Championship run, I think that's one of the sadder things about his career he let his substance abuse get in the way of him becoming a top guy.

[Rorschach]

optimistseatbabies said:

I've always believed if Hall would have stayed with the WWF he would have eventually had World Championship run, I think that's one of the sadder things about his career he let his substance abuse get in the way of him becoming a top guy.

Very true.....had he stayed with the E, and stayed clean, he may have just had that championship run.


I personally always wished wCw would have let him beat Goldberg for the title, and create the fatal crack in the foundation of the nWo.....thus splintering the core group for good. Then, they could have had Hall defect to wCw, and at least give wCw a "cool" guy to root for, while Nash and Hogan feuded over the remains of the nWo.