Who would you rather have as top guy? Roman or Seth?

[ChitownKnight]

Gun to your head, who would you choose? Rollins I feel like is a much better heel and I feel like we ll see him turn in the next year or so (probably a double turn with AJ). Roman winning the title at mania would be a great storyline and I think that is what they are going for

[realist]

I like Roman. He seems like a really good dude, who doesn't come out for a promo on national television in front of a bunch of children and tells them there is no God.

I'm an atheist and I was offended by that.

[adamclark52]

Roman

All hatred aside if it wasn't for bad booking and bad writing (none of which was his doing) he screams "top guy"

Seth is a decent "top heel", but a top heel should never be the face of the company. He's terrible as a face. That's not even taking his current run into account. When he came back from his knee injury it didn't feel right.

[TWERKIN' MAGGLE]

Roman is a better representative of the company these days.

Seth is an immature, thin-skinned little baby.

[Jacy Jayne Atomic Dog AMV]

Roman's pretty boring as a top face, but boring is 1000x better than threatening to assault someone's children and telling an arena full of Americans that god isn't real.

Seth as a face is like Plankton trying to be nice.

[Pushed to the Moon]

Right now Rollins but wishful thinking: Heel Roman.

[TWERKIN' MAGGLE]

Jul 27, 2019 17:55:01 GMT -5 Jacy Jayne Atomic Dog AMV said:

Roman's pretty boring as a top face, but boring is 1000x better than threatening to assault someone's children and telling an arena full of Americans that god isn't real.

Seth as a face is like Plankton trying to be nice.

If God isn't real, why is there a WWE win/loss record?

[H-Virus]

Did I miss something? When did Seth tell everyone there's no God?

[Mozenrath]

Seth is a cardio powerhouse, and a good mix of strength and agility, but he just comes across so insincere and whiny as a face. Or doing interviews, for that matter.

Roman needs revision, but he just is easier to respect, to be honest.

[Deleted]

Jul 27, 2019 18:10:26 GMT -5 H-Virus said:

Did I miss something? When did Seth tell everyone there's no God?

It was a promo in I want to say early 2017. It may have even been the same one where he threatened Stephanie and Triple H's young daughters.

[Deleted]

Neither.

I don’t like the idea of there being a “top guy”... I’d rather we had a bunch of characters on par with each other, who could beat each other on any given day.

I prefer Rollins to Reigns. But Rollins is much better as a heel. He is a lousy babyface cause he’s got barely anything likable about him.

[Cyno]

In terms of matches, I think Rollins tends to have more interesting matches. Roman's offense tends to be incredibly predictable with Superman punches and Spears. Rollins at least can mix it up.

Personality-wise, Roman. Roman at worst was boring, typical WWE "you'll take this and LIKE it damnit!" top face booking we saw with Cena. But Rollins is actively annoying. Sad thing is he had good face booking in 2017 and 2018 and it got pissed away in 2019 to...whatever the hell he is now where he's just completely unlikable.

[Silver Sabre]

Roman

[mcstoklasa]

God, neither.

[A Platypus Rave]

Both are pretty bad at it..

Roman is boring and ill fitting for the role they seemed to want him in (though maybe giving him a friggen consistent personality would help there) and his matches are... pretty bad... and consist of get ass kicked... shrug it off superman punch spear go home.

Seth's matches are generally WAY better and more unique in setup... and while he has a consistent personality it's annoying douche which isn't really fitting for a guy you are supposed to like...

in non wrestling interviews both took the "the WWE is great and doing nothing wrong the fans are just stupid" mindset ... Seth just seems to be shooting his mouth off with more frequency.

Really can't make a choice on this... it's a punch in the right eye or a punch in the left eye...

[nisidhe]

If forced to choose only between the two, I'd go with Roman.

But I honestly think Balor blows both of them out of the water. What it took Vince a year or more to do with Roman, Vince got it with Balor in less than a month.

[Dub H]

Its not like Roman is amazing in PR, his biggest plus to it is that he beat cancer.


At least Rollins can be entertaining.

[Kevin Hamilton]

Reigns by a pretty wide margin.

Though if it was up to me entirely, Rusev.

[Bub (BLM)]

Roman. Every version of him is better than every version of Seth.

[Nickybojelais]

Jul 27, 2019 17:48:25 GMT -5 realist said:

I like Roman. He seems like a really good dude, who doesn't come out for a promo on national television in front of a bunch of children and tells them there is no God.

I'm an atheist and I was offended by that.

That's the first thing I've heard Rollins say recently that I actually approve of!